“You can run my dog,” my ex-husband said at my door, holding his dog show clipboard. He’d promised our daughter he’d learn to do it himself, but he was already looking at me like I’d been assigned the job. I smiled and told him I’d find him a dog he could practice with.

Darren had his collar turned up, like he was about to have his picture taken by a man selling trucks. His pockets were empty, of course. Mine still held the little roll of dog bags that had rattled through the dryer that week.

“Could you at least come in and read the schedule?” I asked.

“No need,” he said. “I made you a list.”

He held out the clipboard. The first job was to brush his dog. The last was to pick him up a breakfast sandwich.

“Did you write this before or after you told Maisie you could handle the club show yourself?”

“The whole thing’s walking around in a circle, Maris.”

“Good. You’ll get your steps in.”

He looked down at the list as if I’d missed the important part. I told him I’d find him a dog he could practice with. He laughed, left the clipboard on my shoe rack, and ducked his head back through the door.

“Get the sandwich without cheese.”

I didn’t throw the clipboard after him. I did think about it.

Maisie was at her own practice that afternoon. The junior handlers were working on taking a dog through a gate without letting go of the leash.

She’d picked Darren’s dog, Otter, for the exercise. She’d worked with him until he knew to wait while she reached for the latch.

When Darren told her friends I’d be coming along as his unpaid assistant, they laughed because he was somebody’s dad. Maisie laughed about half a second after they did.

That was the part I kept hearing.

It had taken a whole year after our divorce before Maisie would invite a friend over on a weekend when her father was coming by. When she started doing that again, I was so pleased I said yes to nearly everything she asked. Sometimes I said yes before she’d even asked. I’d told myself I was keeping things easy for her. I was also making it easy for Darren to assume I’d keep doing his share.

I called Trish, the club instructor, while I was still looking at the sandwich on his list.

“Does he know about your beginner hour?”

“He knows,” she said. “He said you could take notes for him.”

“Could I sign him up if he says yes himself?”

“I’ll leave the spot open. What’s he got to lose?”

“His entire understanding of who does what at a dog show.”

Trish laughed once, then told me to bring the short leash if Darren agreed. She didn’t offer to take him easy on account of his being a father, and I was glad. Maisie didn’t need another grown-up smoothing things over for him.

The next morning I sent Darren the beginner-hour flyer. I said I could work with Maisie and keep Otter out of the way if Darren wanted his own practice.

He texted back asking what they’d make him do.

“Start with getting into the ring,” I told him.

“That won’t take an hour.”

“You might get out in time for breakfast.”

He texted Trish that he’d come. I knew he’d expect me to cave at the last minute and do it for him. For fifteen years, that had been a reasonable guess.

Darren arrived in pressed chinos and the slip-on shoes he said looked professional. I pointed out the patch of sidewalk where the other beginners had lined up. He took the clipboard back and made a show of checking Maisie’s name off his list.

“What if I get called up while you’re over there?”

“Then you’ll be glad you’ve got pockets.”

I gave him the short leash and the bags I’d washed by accident. Then I went with Maisie to the other end of the lot. We put two chairs on their sides to make a gate and practiced turning without pulling Otter’s lead. She went through with the latch end coming toward her knee. Otter sat as if he’d been doing it all his life.

“Dad says you’re doing his ring today,” she said.

“He might have heard me wrong.”

She watched me for a little while before she let Otter through. I worried her first thought was that there was about to be a fight. After a year of watching both our faces in the driveway, I could see why she’d think that.

“I’ll be right here when it’s your turn,” I told her. “If he needs help, he’s got an instructor.”

She handed me Otter and hurried over to show her father the right way to hold his lead. Darren listened, but I could tell he was already looking past her toward the ring.

He came back a minute later.

“Did you talk Trish into going easy on me?”

“I asked her to start you where she starts everybody.”

“How hard can it be to get a dog to stand still?”

He dropped his clipboard on the folding chair by the entrance and walked straight through. I used to watch him walk into a room that way and wish some of it would rub off on me. That morning, I stayed outside the gate, where I’d told Maisie I would be.

Trish pulled the gate shut behind him.

“Did you remember your lead?” she asked.

He held it up.

She took it from him, and I passed Otter over to her. She clipped the lead onto his collar and guided him to Darren. She said this was the only dog she’d found who could match him for beginner experience.

Darren got down low to give Otter the command he’d told Maisie was so easy even I could do it. Trish held the leash out for him to take back. At the end of it was Otter.

Darren looked at the dog. Then he looked at the leash in his hand.

For a second, I thought he might turn the whole thing into a joke. He started to smile, but Otter shifted his feet and looked up at him, waiting.

“What am I supposed to do?” Darren asked.

“Start by standing up,” Trish said. “Keep the leash loose. Let him see where you’re going.”

Darren stood. Otter stood too. Trish stepped back, and the people waiting their turn watched from along the side of the ring. A woman holding a dog by the gate looked down at her own shoes. One of the other beginners gave Darren a small encouraging nod.

He turned to face the ring.

“Come on, Otter.”

Otter moved toward him, then stopped to look at me through the gate. Darren tugged the leash.

“Don’t pull,” Maisie called from beside me.

“I know,” Darren said.

Otter stayed where he was.

Trish stepped closer. “He’s watching your hands. Give him a little room.”

Darren loosened his grip. Otter came forward, and Darren took two steps before looking down to check where the dog was. His shoulders were stiff. He glanced toward the gate, where the other people could see him.

“Keep going,” Trish said. “You’re all right.”

Darren took another step. Otter walked beside him, easy as anything. Maisie smiled, and for a few seconds it looked like he might get through the exercise without turning it into a contest.

Then Darren pulled Otter around too fast at the corner.

“Slow down,” Trish said.

“I am going slow.”

“You’re turning him too sharply.”

“I thought you said this was beginner hour.”

“It is,” Trish said. “That’s why I’m telling you.”

Darren’s jaw tightened. He looked over at Maisie, who was standing very still by the gate. He turned back toward the ring and tried again. This time, he watched Otter instead of the other people. He let the lead hang loose. Otter followed him around the bend.

It was a small thing. I still felt proud of him, which annoyed me. I didn’t want to have to applaud him for paying attention to his own dog.

At the gate, Trish showed him how to stop Otter, reach for the latch, and keep the leash in his other hand. Darren moved too quickly and nearly crowded the dog against the chair. Trish asked him to start again.

He looked down at Otter, then over at Maisie.

“Do I have to do it with everyone watching?”

“You can do it here,” Trish said. “Or you can practice outside with me. But we’re not going to tell Maisie you learned it if you haven’t.”

That landed. Darren’s face changed, though he still tried to keep his voice light.

“I said I’d handle it.”

“You said you could handle it,” Maisie said. “Then you told everyone Mom was doing it for you.”

She didn’t raise her voice. Somehow that made it harder to hear.

Darren set his feet. “I didn’t say she was doing the whole thing.”

“You gave her a list.”

“That was just to keep track.”

“You put a sandwich on it.”

A couple of people looked away. I wanted to step in, to soften the moment. I’d done that so often that my mouth opened before I caught myself.

Darren’s eyes found mine.

“You can’t just stand there and let her talk to me like that.”

I was embarrassed by how quickly the old habit came back. I also knew I’d be more embarrassed later if I rescued him again.

“She’s telling you what happened,” I said. “Let her finish.”

“I’m right here,” Maisie said. Her fingers were curled around the gate, but her voice stayed steady. “I wanted you to come to practice. You said you would learn it. Then you told them Mom would do it.”

Darren looked down at the leash. Otter stood with his head turned toward him, still waiting.

“I thought you were making it sound worse than it was,” Darren said.

“I heard you.”

“I didn’t mean for you to laugh.”

“You told them she’d be your unpaid assistant.”

He rubbed his thumb over the leash handle. “You all laughed.”

“I laughed because they did,” Maisie said. “I didn’t think it was funny.”

Darren’s face got tight. He looked embarrassed, and embarrassed Darren could be mean.

“Maris, you always have to make me look stupid.”

That one hurt because he said it in front of the very people he’d wanted to impress. I’d been standing there, letting him take swings at me for a long time, then pretending the bruise was nothing. That morning I was angry enough to stop pretending.

“I didn’t bring you here to make you look stupid,” I said. “I brought you here because you told Maisie you’d learn.”

“Same difference to you, I guess.”

“No. It isn’t.”

Trish didn’t step between us. She stayed by Otter, letting Darren decide whether he was going to keep talking to me or do the thing he’d come to practice.

Darren looked at the group outside the ring. “I’m supposed to just act like I know what I’m doing?”

“No,” I said. “You’re supposed to learn what you said you’d learn.”

He turned toward Maisie. “I did want to do it myself.”

“Then why’d you ask Mom to do it?”

He started to answer, then stopped. His eyes moved to me and then down to the clipboard on the folding chair. The list was still there, the breakfast sandwich at the bottom.

I could see the answer coming before he said it. I wished he’d said it in a kinder way. I also wished I hadn’t spent so much time acting as if I didn’t already know.

“I didn’t want to stand here and have everybody watch me not know anything,” he said.

Maisie didn’t move. “So you wanted Mom to do it while you took credit?”

“I didn’t say that.”

“You told them she was coming to be your assistant.”

“I thought she’d help me.”

“She already did,” Maisie said. “She brought you here.”

The club was quiet enough that I heard Otter’s tags tap against his collar. I felt my face warming. Part of me wanted Darren to deny it, because then I could be angry without having to feel sorry for him. But he’d said it plainly. He was scared of looking foolish, so he’d planned to put me between himself and the embarrassment.

I hated that I understood it. Understanding didn’t make the list any less insulting.

Darren turned to me. “You could’ve told me this was going to be in front of people.”

“I told you beginner hour.”

“I thought you’d stay with me.”

“I said I’d work with Maisie.”

“Then you should’ve said that more clearly.”

I almost gave him the answer he wanted. Instead I said, “I should’ve stopped saying yes a long time ago.”

The words came out sharper than I meant them to. Maisie looked over at me. I wished I could take that part back, not the truth, just the way I’d dropped it in front of her like another thing she had to hold.

I turned to her. “I’m sorry. This isn’t yours to fix.”

She gave a small nod and looked back at her father.

Darren’s voice went lower. “You could’ve helped me without making a point of it.”

“I’ve helped you for years,” I said. “I helped you because I wanted things to be easier for Maisie. I kept doing it after it was clear you expected me to. That part’s on me. But I’m not doing your dog show for you.”

He stared at me. “Nobody asked you to do the whole show.”

“You put it on the list.”

“That was a joke.”

“It wasn’t funny to me.”

He glanced at the clipboard again. “I didn’t mean all of it literally.”

“You said I could run your dog. You asked me to read your schedule. You told Maisie’s friends I was coming as your assistant. What part should I take as a joke?”

He pressed his lips together. He didn’t have an answer ready, and the people watching were no longer giving him the polite little nods they had earlier.

Trish rested one hand on Otter’s shoulder. “We can keep working,” she said. “But Maris isn’t going to do it for you.”

Darren looked at her. “I know.”

“Do you?” Maisie asked.

He reached for the clipboard and picked it up. For a moment he held it against his side, as if he might take it and leave. Then he looked down at the list and folded it in half.

“I told your friends your mom would help because I was nervous,” he said to Maisie. “I didn’t want to look like I didn’t know what I was doing.”

“You didn’t know what you were doing,” she said.

“I know that now.”

“You could’ve just told me.”

He nodded once. “I should have.”

It wasn’t enough to undo the afternoon before. It wasn’t enough to make me forget the sandwich order. But it was the first time that morning he’d spoken to her without trying to make the problem sound like mine.

Maisie looked down at Otter. “Do you still want to learn?”

Darren glanced toward the people waiting at the ring. “Yes.”

“Then do the gate.”

He bent down beside Otter, this time without rushing. He held the lead where Trish had shown him and waited until the dog looked up. Then he walked him to the chairs. The first try was clumsy. He reached for the latch too soon, and Otter moved with him.

“Start again,” Trish said.

Darren looked at Maisie. She gave him a small shrug, as if there was no reason to make a big thing of starting again.

He took Otter back to the beginning.

This time he stopped before the gate. He kept the lead loose, reached for the latch, and let Otter wait beside him. When he opened it, he guided the dog through without letting go. Otter came out on the other side and sat.

Maisie smiled. She didn’t clap, and neither did I. Trish said, “That’s it. Now do it again.”

Darren did it again.

He made mistakes. He looked down too much and walked too fast at the turn. But he listened when Trish corrected him. He didn’t ask me to take the leash. By the end of the hour, he could get Otter through the gate without crowding him.

When Trish called the practice finished, Darren handed Otter’s lead back to Maisie. He kept hold of the leash until she had a good grip.

“I’m sorry I put that on you,” he said. “And I’m sorry I made your mom sound like she was there to do my work.”

Maisie looked at him for a few seconds. “You should tell my friends that.”

“I will.”

“And don’t make Mom get the sandwich.”

Darren gave a small, rueful smile. “All right.”

He turned toward me. “I’m sorry about the list.”

I could have said it was fine. I could have made him feel better, the way I’d done when he made things uncomfortable. Instead I said, “I’m not picking up your breakfast.”

“I know.”

“I’m not taking notes for you, either.”

“I know that too.”

I didn’t know whether I believed him. That was the part I was nervous to admit. I had been so eager to make sure Maisie got her father at his best that I’d let him hand me the worst parts of the job. One morning of honest talk wasn’t going to make me trust his next promise.

Darren unfolded the list and stared at it. Then he tore it down the crease, once, and put the two halves in his pocket.

“I’ll practice with Otter before the next club day,” he said to Maisie. “If you want me to.”

“I do,” she said. “But you have to do it.”

“I will.”

“Not Mom.”

“Not Mom.”

I was still angry. I was also relieved that Maisie had finally said it to him without looking at me to see if she was allowed. She reached for Otter’s leash, and Darren let her take it.

We went back to the chairs and gave them their proper places. I picked up the short leash from the folding chair and wound it around my hand. Darren stayed beside the ring, asking Trish when the next beginner practice was. He wrote the day on the back of his list, then stopped and asked her to repeat it so he could get it right.

Maisie led Otter through the gate once more. Darren watched her hands this time.

I put the leash in my own pocket and left the clipboard on the chair.

amomana

amomana

6476 articles published