In 1974, Darrell Lockett’s mother ended our church duets with one sentence about my mother. I was twelve. Darrell was thirteen. I didn’t see him again for fifty-two years. “My son won’t stand up there beside a girl whose mama cleans motel rooms,” she said.
Every fifth Sunday, our little church outside Hillsville, Virginia, had dinner on the grounds. After we ate, Darrell and I sang a duet. I sang alto, he sang tenor, and we shared one black hymnbook.
“Softly and Tenderly” was ours. We practiced it on the church steps all spring. Darrell had a cowlick his mama spit-combed flat every Sunday, and he turned the page too early every time.
“You’re a whole line ahead of me,” I’d tell him.
“Then catch up, Jeanie,” he’d say.
Whoever messed up bought the other a Grapette from the machine at the store. I messed up on purpose more than once. I liked making him pay for the soda, and I liked how he pretended to be annoyed.
My mother cleaned rooms at the motor court out on the highway. Six days a week, forty rooms a day. Her hands smelled like bleach till the day she died. Every piano lesson I took came out of that bleach money.
I was proud of her. I was also twelve, and when Mrs. Lockett said what she said, I felt ashamed of the very hands that had paid for my lessons. I hate that I carried that feeling for so long.
That August, Mrs. Lockett walked over to the table where Mama was cutting pies. Darrell and I had just finished singing and sat down. Mrs. Lockett wore a hat with a feather, the kind she wore to church dinner every fifth Sunday.
“My son won’t stand up there beside a girl whose mama cleans motel rooms,” she said.
Her voice carried to every table under those oak trees. I remember the pie server resting beside Mama’s hand. Mama laid it down carefully and wiped her palms on her apron.
Nobody said a word.
Darrell went red clear to his ears. “Mother,” he said. “Please don’t.”
She took him by the arm. Before school started, she sent him to his uncle’s in Ohio. That was the last time we sang together.
I mailed two letters to the Lockett house. It was the only address I knew. I got no answer. By then I was thirteen, and I took the silence for my answer.
Part of it was on me. I never wrote a third time. I was too proud, and I was ashamed of Mama’s hands. That is the part I have always had the hardest time saying out loud.
I married Arnold in 1980, and I’ve been a Pruden ever since. He drove for the lumberyard. We raised two kids. I clerked on the hospital ward for thirty years, and I still work the front desk on Sunday mornings because the pension doesn’t stretch as far as it used to.
Arnold died three years ago, in January. His recliner is still in the den. Nobody sits in it, not even the cat. I sing the alto line of every song on the car radio, the way I always have.
“Where’s the rest of the song, Jeanie?” Arnold used to ask.
“It’s in my head, hon.”
Ten days before I drove to Darrell’s church, my niece Tonia mailed me a bulletin she’d picked up at a funeral over in Wytheville. One line was circled in red ink: After forty-four years, Darrell Lockett will lead our singing one last time this Sunday.
Under it, Tonia had written, “Isn’t this your singing boy?”
I stuck the bulletin on the refrigerator with my peach magnet. I looked at it every morning for a week, usually while I waited for the coffee to finish. I could tell you I was thinking it over. Truth is, I was afraid.
My daughter came by Wednesday and read the bulletin.
“Mama. You were twelve years old.”
“I know how old I was.”
“He’s a stranger now, Mama. He’s a married man.”
“His wife died in the spring, honey. It’s printed right there.”
“And then what?”
I couldn’t answer her. She was asking what I expected to happen if I went, and I didn’t know. I just knew I’d spent fifty-two years singing the alto part by myself.
That night I lay awake doing arithmetic. I’d already asked off two Sundays that year, and my supervisor had said, real sweet, that a third might be a problem. At sixty-four, nobody’s out hiring desk clerks.
“Jeanie Pruden, you old fool,” I thought. “You’ll lose a paycheck over a boy you knew for one summer.”
In the morning, I called and asked off anyway.
I drove the ninety minutes in my good navy dress. I never turned the radio on. At the church, I parked at the far end of the gravel lot, where nobody would see me sitting in the car and wonder why I hadn’t gone in.
A young pastor shook my hand at the door.
“Are you kin to Darrell?”
“I knew him when I was a girl.”
He studied my face gently. “Then sit up close.”
I asked him how Darrell always closed the last Sunday of the month.
“You’ll see,” he said. “There’s a part in it nobody sings.”
I sat in the back anyway. I held the bulletin in both hands till it went soft. I couldn’t tell you one word of the sermon.
Then Darrell stood at the front. He had white hair, a navy blazer, and reading glasses on a cord around his neck. I’d have known him anywhere by the way he tapped the hymnbook twice with two fingers before he started. He did that at thirteen.
“Number four-sixteen,” he said. “Softly and Tenderly.”
Then he looked out over the congregation. “Y’all know the rule. Leave the alto alone.”
They did. The congregation sang the melody, Darrell sang tenor, and the place where my part belonged stayed empty. The whole church left it empty, as if they’d been doing it for years.
I was on my feet before I knew it. I walked up the long aisle in my Sunday shoes, with every head turning toward me. I could hear Mama plain as day: Don’t make a fuss, Jeanie.
I made one anyway.
I came in on the second verse, on the alto, right where I’d left off in 1974. Darrell’s voice stopped. The church carried the next line without him, then trailed off.
He turned the page too early. Of course he did. I reached over and turned it back.
He looked down at my hand on the page, then up into my face.
“Jeanie,” he said. “Mother told me you’d written to say you were ashamed of me and didn’t want me to write.”
I gripped the edge of the hymnbook. My stomach dropped, and then I got mad.
“I wrote you twice,” I said. “I never said that.”
Darrell looked at the page, then back at me. “You wrote?”
“Two letters. To your house. I didn’t know where else to send them.”
He stood still with one hand on the hymnbook. For a few seconds, I could hear people shifting in the pews behind us.
“I never saw them,” he said.
I wanted him to say he’d searched for me, or that he had questioned his mother, or that there was some good reason he had let a whole lifetime go by. Instead, he looked at my face as if he were seeing a part of the story he’d been told for the first time.
The pastor came up beside us, not rushing either of us. “There’s a fellowship room right through that door,” he said. “You can take a minute.”
I almost told Darrell no. I had done the thing I came to do. I had sung my part. But I could not leave the lie sitting there between us, with his congregation still listening.
So I followed him into the room.
The pastor stayed by the doorway. A few people from the congregation came in behind him, then stopped near the coffee table. No one asked for a show. They’d all heard Darrell’s voice stop, and they’d all seen me walk up the aisle.
Darrell set the hymnbook on the table. His hand shook once, just enough for me to notice.
“Tell me what you remember,” he said.
I pulled a chair out but stayed standing. “I remember you turning the page too early. I remember you telling me to catch up.”
His mouth moved a little, almost a smile. “I remember the Grapette machine.”
“I remember you always picked the cold one.”
“I thought that was the point.”
We both laughed, though mine came out thin. Then the laughter was gone.
“I wrote two letters,” I said. “The first one was mostly about school. I asked if you still had the music. The second one said you still turned the page too early, and I hoped your uncle’s house was all right.”
He pressed his lips together. “Mother told me you wanted me to leave you alone.”
“That’s not what I wrote.”
“I believe you.”
He said it quickly, but it didn’t make fifty-two years disappear. I looked at him and saw the boy who had blushed under the oak trees, then the old man who had kept the alto line empty.
“Why did you believe her?” I asked.
He glanced toward the doorway. The pastor looked down at his hands, giving us a little space without leaving.
“I was thirteen,” Darrell said. “She told me you were ashamed of me. It fit what she’d said about your mama. I wanted to think she knew what was best.”
“That’s an answer,” I said. “It isn’t a reason.”
“No,” he said. “It isn’t.”
He took off his glasses and folded them. “I asked about you once. Years later. Mother said you’d married and didn’t want to hear from me. I let that be enough.”
I looked down at the hymnbook. It was open to the song we used to sing. The paper had softened at the edges from years of hands turning it.
“Did you ever try to find me?”
“No.” He put the glasses back on. “I could have. I didn’t.”
The plainness of that hurt more than a long excuse would have. I was angry with him. I was also angry that I had never sent a third letter, as if the responsibility had been mine to keep knocking forever.
“I’m sorry,” he said. “I should have questioned her. I should have tried to find you.”
I nodded once. I wasn’t ready to make it easy for him. “You should have.”
The pastor stepped in then. “Darrell, people heard you say she didn’t want you to write. They should hear the rest from you, too.”
Darrell looked at the people gathered in the doorway. His face had gone red again, not like a boy this time. He was embarrassed, and he didn’t look away.
“I told you my mother said Jeanie wanted no contact,” he said. “Jeanie has just told me she wrote twice. I never saw those letters. I should not have told her story for her.”
A woman near the coffee table lowered the cup in her hand. Another person looked at me and nodded. Nobody clapped. I was grateful. This was a family wound, even if most of the family was gone.
Darrell added, “I don’t know what happened to the letters. I’m not going to pretend I do.”
That mattered. He didn’t claim to have proof of what his mother had done. He didn’t ask me to take his word about her. He only owned the part he knew: he had believed the story because it was easier than finding out for himself.
I let out a breath. “I was ashamed of Mama’s hands once. I’m ashamed of that now. But I never asked you to disappear.”
He looked down. “I’m sorry.”
“Don’t say it just because everyone’s here.”
“I’m saying it because you’re here.”
That was not enough to repair the years. It was enough for me to hear him.
The pastor asked if we wanted to go back to the sanctuary. Darrell looked at me before answering.
“Would you sing the last verse with me?”
I glanced at the hymnbook. “You’re still turning pages early?”
“I’m afraid so.”
I almost smiled. “Then you’ll have to wait for me.”
We went back together. I could feel the congregation watching, but nobody tried to hurry us. Darrell stood at the front with the hymnbook open. He tapped it twice with two fingers, then waited.
His voice came in on the tenor. Mine came in on the alto. The congregation joined the melody behind us.
For once, Darrell turned the page at the right time. I reached over and kept it open for him anyway.
When the song ended, he closed the book and thanked the congregation for coming. He said it would be his last Sunday leading the singing, just as the bulletin had promised. He didn’t add anything about our history. He didn’t need to.
I left before the coffee was gone. At the door, Darrell asked if he could call me sometime.
“You can,” I said. “But don’t tell me what I wanted. Ask me.”
He nodded. “I will.”
I drove home with the radio off. At the first stoplight, I caught myself humming the alto line. This time, I let it carry all the way through.