In 1976, the boy I loved left for the Army. Fifty years later, he walked into our class reunion and still knew I take my Coke with lime. Then my older brother marched across the cafeteria floor and told him, in front of everybody, “Go back to Arizona, Gil.”

I was standing at the punch table when Gil spoke behind me. Nell, who was helping with the reunion, had just pinned my name tag to my blouse. I had one hand around a glass of Coke, and I turned at the sound of a voice I hadn’t heard in half a century.

“Coke with a squeeze of lime. Still?” he asked.

It was Gil Ybarra. His hair had gone gray, and he wore a cap that said he’d served in Germany. But his front tooth still leaned a little crooked, just as it had when we were teenagers.

“Flora Dunlap,” he said. “I’d know you anywhere.”

“It’s Teague now,” I said. “Or it was. My husband passed.”

“My wife too,” he said. “Three years ago this Christmas.”

We looked at each other for a few seconds, both of us trying to fit the young faces we remembered over the older ones standing there. He said he’d been in Mesa, Arizona, for almost forty-five years. Then he handed me a Coke with a lime wedge on the rim.

I hadn’t had one fixed that way since 1976. I can’t say I was overwhelmed by the drink.

It was just a small thing, but it made the years between us feel less solid.

My name is Flora Teague. I was Flora Dunlap when Gil left for basic training. I was eighteen, living in Monahans, Texas, and certain that a boy who loved me would come back and we’d figure the rest out together.

He left in his good shirt. I cried so hard I couldn’t get a proper goodbye out. I thought we would write. We did, for a while, but then there were gaps, and I let the quiet tell me what I was afraid was true.

I was wrong about that. I didn’t know it then.

My older brother, Dub, was four years ahead of me. Since my husband Loy died six years ago, Dub had taken to driving me wherever he thought I needed to go. He drove me to the grocery store, to appointments, and to the reunion, whether I’d asked or not.

Loy had been a good, quiet man. He fixed pumps in the oil field and never once raised his voice to me. I loved him, and I don’t want to make a false story out of my marriage just because Gil came back into my life with a remembered lime wedge.

I sold farm, home, and auto insurance in town for forty years. I spent my working life looking at forms and watching people press their pens too hard when they were nervous. It embarrasses me to admit I didn’t recognize a lie when it came from my own brother.

At the reunion, Gil and I talked by the punch table until the DJ put on a slow song. He held out his hand. I looked at it, then at him, and took it.

We danced carefully. Our knees weren’t what they had been at the Ward County fair, but our feet seemed to remember the old steps. I put my head against his shoulder. He smelled of Old Spice, and for a few minutes I could see us at eighteen without trying.

Then somebody caught my arm.

Dub was beside me. His face was red, and his hand shook as he held on. The music kept playing, but the conversation around us fell away.

“Go back to Arizona, Gil,” Dub said. “She doesn’t need you stirring up old things.”

Gil let go of my hand. He didn’t answer Dub. He only looked at me, gave a small nod, and walked out the side door.

I yanked my arm free. My anger came up fast, and beneath it was a hurt I couldn’t yet name.

“Dub, what on earth is wrong with you?” I said.

“I’m taking you home,” he said. “You’re not thinking straight.”

“I’m sixty-eight years old. I’m thinking fine.”

I followed Gil through the side door before Dub could decide what else I wasn’t capable of doing. Gil was sitting on the cafeteria steps beneath the outside light, holding his cap in both hands. I sat down next to him. For a while, neither of us found a place to start.

Then he turned the cap over in his hands.

“Can I ask you something I’ve wanted to ask for forty-nine years?”

“Okay,” I said.

“When I got home from Germany, the fall of ’77, I came straight to your mama’s house.

I had a ring in my pocket. I’d saved for it the whole time over there. Why didn’t you come to the door?”

I stared at him. I could hear the muffled music through the wall, but it sounded far away.

“Gil, I never knew you came.”

He studied my face, searching for a reason to think I was lying.

“Dub answered,” he said. “He told me you were engaged to Loy Teague and didn’t want to see me. He said you asked him to tell me to go.”

“I didn’t meet Loy until 1979,” I said. My voice came out thin. “That was the fall Mama got sick. I sat with her every night and waited for you.”

Then I told him what I’d carried all those years.

“I thought you forgot me over there.”

Gil covered his eyes with one hand. He had gone to our house with a ring, and I had been waiting for a letter, a visit, or any sign he still wanted me. We had both believed what Dub told us.

“I gave Dub the ring,” Gil said. “I told him to give it to you, so you’d at least know I came back for you.”

Gil had left for El Paso that same night. He said he had his pride, and he thought I’d made my choice. He never came back to Monahans.

The truth was sitting between us on those steps, but it couldn’t return a single year. I felt foolish for all the times I’d wondered what I’d done wrong. I also felt mad enough to walk right back into the cafeteria and ask Dub the question in front of everyone.

Inside, the DJ was playing Earth, Wind & Fire. On the steps, I kept looking at Gil’s hands while he told me how long he’d kept the ring’s empty place in his life.

I didn’t know what to say to him. I didn’t know what I wanted from him, either. I knew only that I had spent my whole life believing I’d been the one who left.

Gil took a folded reunion program from his pocket. On the back, he wrote his phone number and held it out to me.

“If you want to talk again,” he said, “you can call.”

I folded it and put it in my purse. Then I walked back inside, found my coat, and let Dub drive me home in silence. He stared through the windshield the whole way.

That night I sat beneath Mama’s yellow quilt, the one with the stars, and shook so hard I had to hold my hands together. Dub had driven me everywhere since Loy died. I had let myself think that was only kindness.

I called Nell. I trusted her, and she had seen Dub grab me at the reunion.

“Don’t go over there,” Nell said. “Flora, Dub is all the family you have left. You go start this, and he’ll never speak to you again.”

I held the phone against my ear and stared at the folded program on the table. Nell had a point. Dub was my brother. But the fact that he had been good to me since Loy died didn’t make the lie smaller.

“Maybe you’re right,” I said.

I hung up and went to bed. I didn’t sleep much. I thought about what Gil had said, and I thought about Mama sick in the house, and the years I had spent sitting with her. I wondered if I’d lost Gil because I had been too proud, or too slow, or too sure that silence meant rejection.

I was nervous to say it even to myself: part of me had been grateful to Dub for taking care of me, and now I felt like a fool for trusting him.

At seven the next morning, I got into my car. I didn’t drive at night anymore because of my cataracts, but it was daylight, and I knew the way to Dub’s house on the Kermit highway. It was six miles out, in Daddy’s old house.

I kept both hands on the wheel. When I pulled into the yard, Dub’s truck was there. I walked up the porch steps, and before I could knock, the door opened.

Dub stood there in his undershirt. He hadn’t slept either. In his big oil-field hand was a little velvet ring box, gone gray with dust. He held it out to me, and his chin shook like a little boy’s.

“Sissy,” he said, “the night before Gil came to the door, Mama told me she couldn’t bear for you to leave her.”

That was the answer. Mama had been sick, and she was frightened. She’d told Dub she didn’t want me going away with Gil. She needed me close. She was my mother, and I was the one sitting beside her bed each night.

I looked at the box in his hand.

“Did she tell you to lie to me?” I asked.

“No,” he said. He glanced at the porch floor. “She didn’t say that.”

“Did she tell you to lie to Gil?”

“No.”

He held out the box again, but I didn’t take it yet.

“Mama was scared,” Dub said. “I could hear it in her voice. You were all she wanted near her. I thought if Gil took you away, I wouldn’t see either of you.”

“So you told him I was engaged.”

“Yes.”

“And you told me nothing.”

He pressed his lips together. He didn’t deny it.

“I didn’t know what else to do,” he said. “You were waiting for him. Mama was sick. I thought he’d take you off to Arizona, and then I’d be left there with her.”

The words explained why he had done it. They didn’t make the choice right. He had decided that my life could be changed without my knowing, because he was frightened and because Mama needed me.

I took the ring box from him. The velvet felt rough where the nap had worn away. It was lighter than I expected. For almost fifty years, I’d imagined Gil’s ring in somebody else’s hand, or in a drawer somewhere, or thrown out. I never imagined it in my brother’s pocket.

“You kept this all these years,” I said.

“I couldn’t give it to you after I told him that.”

“Why not tell me later?”

Dub rubbed one palm over the other. “At first I thought I’d tell you when Mama was better. Then she wasn’t getting better. Then time went by. You met Loy. I figured telling you would only hurt you.”

“That was your decision too.”

“I know.”

He had wanted to keep me near Mama, and then he had been too ashamed to undo what he’d done. After I married Loy, he could tell himself the lie had become old news. When Gil walked back into that cafeteria, Dub had seen the secret standing in front of him with a gray head and a crooked tooth.

“Why did you tell him to go last night?” I asked.

His eyes lifted to mine. “Because he came back and looked at you like he still had a right to you.”

“He didn’t claim a right to me.”

“I know.” Dub took a breath. “I just couldn’t watch him take you away.”

“I’m not something you get to keep.”

He looked down again. I had never heard myself say that to him before. I had spent years letting him decide whether the road was safe, whether I ought to go out, when he would pick me up. He had been helpful, and I’d been grateful. I’d also let gratitude make me quiet when I should have spoken up.

“I was trying to protect you,” he said.

“From what? From choosing for myself?”

His mouth tightened. That answer had no soft place to land.

He put both hands on his knees. “I was wrong.”

I looked at the box. Then at him. He was my brother, the boy who’d once walked me home after school and the man who’d driven me since Loy died. He was also the man who had shut a door in Gil’s face and let me believe for decades that Gil had forgotten me.

“If I go talk to Gil, you might not like what I decide,” I said. “You might be angry with me again.”

Dub’s eyes filled, and he wiped at them with the heel of his hand.

“I can’t tell you not to go,” he said.

“You’re telling me now because I came here.”

He didn’t answer. I hated that he had made me say it, and I hated that I still wanted him to be the brother I thought I had.

I went inside long enough to set the box on Daddy’s old kitchen table. Dub followed me but stayed by the doorway. I could hear the refrigerator run. I could see the little box, dust caught in the crease of its lid.

“Did Mama know you kept it?” I asked.

“No.”

“Did Gil ever ask you for it?”

Dub shook his head. “He didn’t come back.”

I sat down, then stood again. I couldn’t settle. My mind kept returning to the reunion, to Gil on the steps, to the small program with his number written on it. If I walked away from Dub without saying what I needed to say, he could pretend the morning had ended with a confession and a box. Maybe he was right about me. Maybe I was making a family wound worse by asking him to face what he’d done.

But maybe I was done letting fear decide for me.

“Give me the ring,” I said.

Dub pushed the box across the table. I opened it. Inside was a plain gold ring, dulled with age. I held it carefully in my palm.

“Gil saved for this while he was overseas,” I said.

“Yes.”

“He trusted you with it.”

“Yes.”

“And you kept it from both of us.”

Dub nodded. His eyes stayed on the ring. He looked smaller than he had at the reunion, but I wasn’t ready to comfort him.

I closed the box. “I want you to tell Gil the truth yourself.”

He looked at me sharply. “You want me to go with you?”

“No. I want you to tell him. Not because I’m bringing you along. Because he deserves to hear you say what you did.”

“What if he won’t see me?”

“Then you’ll have to live with that.”

Dub flinched, and I regretted the way I’d said it. I didn’t take it back. He’d had the chance to tell the truth for years. I wasn’t going to soften the consequence for him because it hurt to watch him feel ashamed.

“I don’t know if I can,” he said.

“You could do it when you told him to leave.”

His face changed at that. He looked down at his hands, the same hands that had held the ring and had grabbed my arm on the dance floor.

I put the box in my purse. I wasn’t handing it back to him, and I wasn’t going to let him decide what happened to it next.

“I’ll call you when I’m ready to talk,” I said.

“Sissy, don’t cut me out.”

“I’m not cutting you out. I’m telling you I need time, and you don’t get to drive me around as if last night didn’t happen.”

He nodded once. I could tell he wanted to say more. He didn’t ask me to stay.

On the porch, I took out the reunion program and looked at Gil’s number. It was still there, written on the back in his careful hand. I had a choice to make, and it was mine this time.

I called him from the car. When he answered, I could hear a little traffic behind him.

“Gil, it’s Flora.”

He was quiet for a beat. “I hoped you’d call.”

“Dub gave me the ring.”

Another pause. “He did?”

“Yes. He told me the truth about Mama. She was afraid I’d leave her, and he decided to keep me there. He lied to you, and he let me believe you forgot me.”

Gil let out a slow breath. “I wondered if that was it.”

“You knew?”

“I knew Dub had lied about you being engaged. I didn’t know why. I didn’t know what was happening with your mama.”

I gripped the phone. “He wants to tell you himself.”

“Does he?”

“He said he would. I told him he owes you that much.”

Gil didn’t answer right away. Then he said, “I don’t need him to come with you, Flora.”

“He won’t. I want to see you. I want to talk without him deciding where I go.”

“I’d like that.”

We agreed to meet at the cafeteria later that day, where the reunion committee was still clearing away decorations. It was an ordinary place, and neither of us had to pretend we were eighteen. I put the ring box in my purse and drove there alone.

Gil was waiting outside the side door. When he saw me, he didn’t reach for my hand or try to draw me close. He let me choose how near to stand.

I handed him the box.

“I don’t know what to do with this,” I said.

He looked down at it. “You don’t have to decide today.”

“I know. I just couldn’t leave it with Dub.”

Gil took the box, then held it between us. He looked sad, but not angry with me. That kindness almost undid me.

“I am sorry,” I said. “I thought you stopped caring. I thought I hadn’t mattered enough for you to come back.”

“You did matter. You mattered enough that I believed what I didn’t want to believe, because I was young and proud.”

“I wish you’d come back to ask me yourself.”

“So do I.”

We sat on the cafeteria steps again. We talked about our spouses, about Mesa, about Monahans, about what we’d each done with the years. We didn’t try to make the years disappear. I told him I had loved Loy, and I told him there had been a place in my memory that I never managed to close.

Gil listened without trying to make one love cancel the other.

When we stood, he asked if I wanted to have coffee with him the next day. I said yes. It wasn’t a promise about the rest of our lives. It was a promise about tomorrow, and I was ready to make that one.

I drove home by myself. The ring box sat on the passenger seat, and the reunion program lay beside it. That evening, I set the box on Mama’s yellow quilt and smoothed the worn velvet lid with my thumb.

amomana

amomana

6446 articles published