In 1966, a boy and I won the county fair square dance, and now his daughter wouldn’t let me see him. “Daddy has Alzheimer’s, and most days he doesn’t know me,” she wrote. I asked for ten minutes and brought the fiddle record we’d danced to all summer. When it started to play, he looked up at me and held out his hand.
I was sixteen that summer, skinny, with a ponytail, living in a little ranch town north of Phoenix. Myron was seventeen and had the biggest ears in Arizona. We were partners on the 4-H square-dance team, and we practiced in a barn that smelled like hay and motor oil.
He never once stepped on my feet. I used to tease him that it was the only reason I kept dancing with him. He’d grin and say he was paying attention.
In August, we won the blue ribbon at the county fair. Somebody’s daddy took our picture. I was in a gingham skirt, caught mid-twirl. Myron was laughing, holding my hand up high. I remember the heat of the fairground and how proud I was when they pinned that ribbon on us.
That September, his mother sent him off to a military school in New Mexico for his senior year. She said his grades were slipping and he was getting too serious about a girl at seventeen. I was young enough to think one letter could change the whole shape of things.
He wrote me one. “Save me the first dance when I get home.”
He never came home to stay. His family moved to Texas the next year, and life went on whether I was ready or not. I grew up, married a good man named Bernard, and worked forty years as a bank teller in Scottsdale. Bernard died three years ago this month.
I’ve been doing fine. I do my crossword every morning, usually before I’ve even finished my coffee, and my granddaughter comes over on Sundays. Last spring, she told me, “Grandma Izzy, you need a hobby,” and set me up on Facebook. I wasn’t looking for anything in particular. I was mostly trying to understand how people found old classmates.
That was how I found Myron. A woman in Payson had posted a birthday picture for her father. “Happy 77th to the best daddy in the world.” There he was, gray and bald, with those same big ears, holding up a faded blue fair ribbon.
I sat at my kitchen table with my hand over my mouth. I stared at the picture, then went back to it after I’d closed the page. I knew it was him. Still, I worked up the nerve for a week before I wrote to his daughter.
Her name was Rochelle. I told her who I was and that Myron and I had danced together at the county fair. I tried to keep the message simple. I didn’t want to sound like I was claiming some grand place in his life after all those years.
She wrote back the next morning. “Ma’am, Daddy has Alzheimer’s, and most days he doesn’t know me. Please don’t come and upset him.”
I read that about forty times. It wasn’t cruel. I could tell she loved him. But it felt like a door shutting in my face sixty years late. I cried at my kitchen table like I was sixteen again, and I felt foolish for letting a Facebook picture do that to me.
I told my friend Coralie at the senior center. She’d been a nurse for thirty years, and she listened while I tried to make a case for going.
“Honey, if he looks at you like a stranger, it’ll break your heart,” she said. “Let him stay seventeen in your head.”
Maybe she was right. Maybe I was a silly old woman chasing a boy who didn’t exist anymore. I kept thinking about his letter, though. Save me the first dance. I finally wrote Rochelle back.
“I’ll only stay ten minutes, and I’ll bring something of ours. If it upsets him, I’ll go.”
She didn’t answer for three days. When her address came through, I read it twice and put it in my purse. On Saturday, I drove up the mountain to Payson with the little portable record player my granddaughter had given me for Christmas. In my purse was the old 45 of the fiddle tune we’d danced to all summer. I’d kept it through four moves and one husband.
Rochelle opened the door with her arms crossed.
“Ten minutes,” she said.
“Ten minutes,” I said.
Myron sat in a recliner by the window, wearing a brown cardigan and looking out at the pines.
He looked at me the way you’d look at a mailman. Polite. Empty.
“Daddy, this lady knew you a long time ago,” Rochelle said.
“That’s nice,” he said, and turned back to the window.
That about finished me. My eyes filled up so fast I had to look at the floor. I was already thinking about how to leave without making Rochelle feel she had to ask me twice.
Then I saw the dresser beside his chair. In a little brass frame was our picture. Me in the gingham skirt, mid-twirl. Myron laughing, my hand raised in his.
Rochelle saw me looking at it.
“That’s been by his bed my whole life,” she said slowly. “Mama said it was his little sister who died young.”
“He didn’t have a sister,” I said.
She sat down on the arm of the couch like somebody had let the air out of her. I set the record player on the coffee table and put on the record. The first scratch came through, then the fiddle tune, fast and sweet. My stomach tightened as the familiar sound filled the room.
Myron’s foot began tapping. Then his hand moved against the arm of the chair.
Rochelle whispered, “He hasn’t done that in two years.”
He turned his head from the window, slow. He looked up at me and held out his hand the way he had in that hay barn.
“Izzy-girl,” he said. “You came back.”
That was the name he’d used when we were kids. Nobody had called me that since. I put my hand in his, and he curled his fingers around mine.
I wanted to cry, but I was afraid I’d make him think something was wrong. So I bent close enough for him to hear me over the record.
“I came back,” I said.
He looked at my face as if he was trying to place me. His eyes moved to the record player, then to the photograph. He tapped his fingers against mine.
“Did you save me the first dance?” he asked.
The words caught in my throat. He had written that in the only letter he ever sent me.
“I did,” I said. “You didn’t come home, though.”
He watched me for a few seconds. Then he shook his head, almost like he was correcting himself.
“I didn’t,” he said.
I could hear the fiddle running on, bright and quick. I laughed once through my tears, because there was no other way to answer that without coming apart.
Rochelle stood just behind the couch. Her arms weren’t crossed anymore. She looked from my hand in his to the picture on the dresser.
“Daddy,” she said, “do you remember her?”
He rubbed his thumb once across my knuckles. “Izzy-girl,” he said again. “We danced.”
I can’t tell anyone what Alzheimer’s will let a person remember from one hour to the next. I can only tell what happened there. Myron knew my old name. He knew the song. He knew we had danced. Then he looked at me again with the polite, uncertain expression he’d had before.
Rochelle lowered herself onto the couch. Her face had changed, but she didn’t look relieved yet. She looked like she was trying to take in two things at once: that her father had reached for me, and that the story she’d heard about the picture wasn’t true.
I didn’t want to push him. I also didn’t want to pretend that moment hadn’t happened.
“Rochelle,” I said, “I’m not asking him to remember everything. I just wanted to see him.”
She wiped at one cheek with the back of her hand. “You don’t get to use him to settle something from when you were teenagers.”
That was a cruel thing to say, and it hurt. I’d been trying not to make this about myself, but I’d also driven all that way hoping for some part of the boy I remembered. I wanted to tell her I wasn’t using him. Instead, I said, “I know how this looks. I don’t have a good answer for all of it.”
She glanced at her father. He was looking down at our joined hands now, as if they belonged to a dance he could almost hear.
“I’m scared he’ll get upset,” Rochelle said. “He gets confused. He thinks people are leaving. Some days he doesn’t know me, and I’m right here.”
“I’m sorry,” I said. And I meant it. I hadn’t understood how much of her life had been spent watching him lose his way.
She nodded toward the photograph. “My mother told me that was his sister. I asked when I was little. She said it was a sister who died.”
“Myron never had a sister,” I said. “That’s me.”
“I know that now.” She pressed her lips together. “I didn’t know you. I thought you were going to come in here and ask him to be the boy in that picture.”
“I was afraid of that too,” I said. “I told myself I could handle it if he didn’t know me. I’m not sure I was telling the truth.”
For a few seconds, neither of us spoke. Myron’s fingers loosened around mine. I didn’t take that as a sign to hold tighter. I let his hand rest where it wanted.
Rochelle leaned toward him. “Daddy, this is Izzy. You danced with her.”
He looked up. “Izzy.”
“That’s right,” I said.
He kept looking at me, and I saw him searching. His brow pulled in, then eased. “You had a skirt,” he said. “A blue one?”
“Gingham,” I said. “It was blue and white.”
He looked at the photograph. “That’s right.”
Rochelle stared at the picture, then at him. She seemed to want to ask how he could remember that and not remember her, but she didn’t. I understood why she might have wanted to. I was afraid of the answer myself.
“I’m not going to ask him to dance,” I said. “Not unless he wants to.”
“I’m not asking you to leave,” she said. “I just don’t want to see him hurt.”
“I don’t want that either.”
Myron’s foot kept tapping to the music, though his eyes had drifted back to the window. I could feel his hand resting on mine, but he wasn’t holding it anymore. Rochelle watched him, then went to the record player and turned the volume down a little.
“Maybe this is enough for today,” she said.
I nodded. My ten minutes had passed, and I didn’t want to make her regret letting me in. I picked up the record sleeve and waited while the tune finished. When I lifted the needle, Myron’s foot stopped.
He turned toward the quiet.
“Where’d the fiddle go?” he asked.
Rochelle looked at me. I didn’t want to decide for her, and I didn’t want to leave without answering him.
“It’s right here,” I said. “Would you like it again?”
He looked from me to the player. “Yes.”
Rochelle gave a small nod. I set the needle back at the beginning. The scratch came first, then the fiddle. Myron’s foot started up again. This time Rochelle sat beside the recliner and watched him.
I was glad she stayed. I was also angry that she’d kept me away before she knew what the song might mean. I didn’t say that then. I knew she’d been trying to protect the father she still had, and I’d been trying to reach the boy I had lost. Neither of us knew what the visit would ask of us.
When the tune ended again, Myron’s eyes had closed. His hand rested on the chair arm. Rochelle touched his shoulder, and he opened his eyes.
“Are you tired, Daddy?”
“A little.”
She looked at me. “That’s probably enough.”
“I understand.”
I gathered the record and the player. Myron watched me move toward the door. I was ready to leave without another word, so he wouldn’t have to watch me go for long.
“Save me the first dance,” he said.
I turned around. He was looking at the window again, and his face had gone distant. I couldn’t tell whether he knew he’d said it. I didn’t ask him to explain.
“I did,” I said. “I saved it.”
In the car, I sat with my hands on the steering wheel before I started the engine. I was relieved he’d recognized me. I was heartbroken that it might be the only time. I was mad at myself for wanting it to mean he was coming back to me, when I knew better.
That evening, Rochelle sent me a message. She said she was sorry she’d spoken to me that way. She also said she was sorry she’d believed the story about the picture without ever asking why it had stayed beside his bed for so long.
“I was trying to keep him from getting upset,” she wrote. “I should have listened to what you said.”
I read it, put my phone down, and finished the crossword I’d left unfinished that morning. I didn’t answer right away. I was still stung, and I didn’t want to write something sharp just because I could.
The next day, I wrote back that I understood why she was scared. I told her I wouldn’t come by without checking with her first. I asked if she’d let me visit again for a short while, even if Myron didn’t know who I was that day.
She said yes.
When I went back, I brought the same record player and the same 45. Rochelle let me in. She didn’t call it a favor, and I didn’t make her.
Myron was in the recliner again. He looked at me for a long time before he spoke.
“Are you the girl who dances?” he asked.
“I was,” I said.
He glanced toward Rochelle. “Did I do all right?”
“You did,” she told him.
I sat nearby while the fiddle played. I didn’t ask him to hold my hand. I didn’t ask him to remember the fair, or the barn, or the letter. I let the song run to the end.
When I stood to leave, Rochelle walked me to the door.
“Come back next Saturday?” she asked.
“If that works for you.”
“It does,” she said.
The following Saturday, I took the record out of its sleeve and set it by the player. Rochelle opened the door before I knocked twice.
Myron looked toward the music as I lowered the needle. His foot began tapping beside the window.