Two years after Monte retired, he started leaving every morning at six and telling me he was going for coffee with the boys. He came home smelling of a woman’s perfume, and then I found $18,000 missing from our savings. When I followed his truck to a grocery store in the next town, I walked into the flower department and a young woman looked at me and said, “You’re Rosalie, aren’t you?”
The first morning, I heard his truck start in the dark and thought maybe he was sick. By the second week, his side of the bed was cold when I woke up. By the third, he wasn’t kissing me goodbye.
Monte and I had been married forty-nine years. He’d spent thirty-eight of them working at the lumber mill outside West Plains. I ran the register at the pharmacy downtown for forty years. I used to say I could spot a lie before the change was counted out. Turns out, knowing the shape of a lie doesn’t make it easier when it’s your husband’s.
For the first two years after he retired, he slept until seven-thirty and drank coffee with me on the porch. Every winter morning of our marriage, he’d go outside first and warm up my side of the car. I trusted the man who did that. I still did, even when the new routine started to bother me.
In the spring, a man began calling the house and asking for Monte.
He was friendly, and Monte always took the call out on the porch. When I asked, Monte said it was a financial fella offering a better rate on our savings.
I’d always handled the groceries, and Monte had always handled the bank. I let him take care of it. I know now I should’ve asked more. At the time, it seemed like one of the ordinary arrangements a couple makes without keeping score.
Then in August, Monte began leaving at six. I’d be getting my coffee ready when I’d hear his truck. He’d come home after lunch, wash at the utility sink, and head straight for the shower.
“Where are you going, Monte?” I asked one morning.
“Coffee with the boys at the gas station,” he said, picking up his keys.
He’d never been much of a morning coffee-with-the-boys man. Still, I wanted to believe him, so I did for a while. That’s a candid thing to admit, but it was easier than looking straight at what was changing.
One day I picked his shirt out of the hamper. It smelled like roses and a sweeter scent, the kind I associated with an older woman’s perfume. I asked him about it once.
“Monte, where do you go all morning?”
He set his fork down hard enough to make me look at his hand.
“A man can’t have coffee with the boys?” he snapped. “Lord have mercy, Rosalie, you sound like a detective.”
He’d never talked to me like that in all our years together. I went to the bathroom and ran the water so he wouldn’t hear me crying. I was ashamed of that, and a little angry at myself. But I was more afraid of what the answer might be.
My sister Neva lives two streets over. I called her from the porch that night.
“Rosie, a man that age with a new routine has a new woman,” she said.
“Monte’s seventy-seven.”
“So’s Delbert Kessinger, and he left Ola for the lady who cuts his toenails.”
I laughed at that, and then I didn’t. Neva had a way of making a thing sound funny so you could stand to hear it.
Every month, on the morning of the third, I checked our checking account after the Social Security deposit came in. I did it at the kitchen table with my reading glasses and coffee. I hadn’t checked savings all summer.
On October third, I opened it. The deposit was there in checking. Then I tapped on the savings account and saw it was down $18,000. The large withdrawal had happened in July.
That money was meant for our fiftieth anniversary. For eleven years, I’d put a little away at a time for the Grand Canyon. We planned to take the train up to the South Rim. A postcard of it was stuck to our refrigerator with a magnet shaped like a mule.
I sat at the table and looked from the account to the postcard. My hands went numb. The thought of all those years of setting money aside being gone hurt almost as much as the thought of Monte giving it to someone else.
He came home at one-fifteen, smelling like flowers again. I was still sitting in the kitchen.
“Our savings is short eighteen thousand dollars,” I said.
He stopped in the doorway with his keys in his hand. His face changed, but he didn’t come toward me.
“I’ll handle it,” he said.
“Handle what?”
“I said I’ll handle it, Rosie.”
Then he went to take his shower. I sat there angry, hurt, and still trying to make room for the idea that perhaps there was an explanation I hadn’t thought of.
That evening I called Neva from the porch.
“I’m going to follow him,” I said.
“Rosalie, you listen to me,” she said. “If you push him and he leaves, you can’t keep that house on your Social Security alone.”
She was right about the house. I was seventy-five, and I had never paid a light bill by myself. The fear sat with me after I hung up.
Lying awake, I pictured some younger woman in my kitchen, sitting in my chair and wearing my apron. I pictured myself at Thanksgiving with no one to pass the dressing to. I hate admitting it, but I wondered if a woman my age ought to be glad for what she had and stop asking.
Then I pictured the money we’d saved and the Grand Canyon postcard on the fridge. It was my money, too. And it was my forty-nine years.
After three months of this, one Monday I got up at five and sat in the dark with my shoes on. At six, Monte left. I counted to a hundred, then grabbed my keys and followed.
I hadn’t driven in the dark in years. I held the wheel so tight my rings hurt. Monte passed the gas station without slowing down and drove out to the highway. He pulled into the lot behind the big grocery store in the next town over, where we never shopped.
I parked near the cart corral and sat for twenty minutes. Women came and went. One young woman wore scrubs. Another had her hair done up and looked about fifty. I wondered if either of them was the one. Then I told myself to get out of the car.
The automatic doors opened, and the grocery-store cold hit me. I walked past the bananas, the pumpkins, and stacks of pop. I couldn’t see Monte. I went down the bread aisle, then cereal, then paper towels.
Near the front windows, I smelled roses and that sweet perfume again. It was coming from the flower department. Buckets crowded the coolers. A man’s denim jacket hung on a hook beside the cooler door. It was Monte’s, with the elbow I’d patched in March.
My legs began to shake. I held on to a cart.
Someone behind the cooler laughed. It was a young woman’s laugh. My first thought was to turn around and walk straight back out. I’d driven all that way in the dark, though, and I couldn’t make myself leave without finding out.
I pushed the cart to the counter. The cooler door swung open, and a young woman in a green apron came out carrying an armful of carnations. She looked about thirty and had a ponytail. Her name tag was turned away from me.
She took one look at my face and stopped. The carnations began to slide in her arms.
“Oh my Lord,” she said. “You’re Rosalie, aren’t you?”
“How do you know my name?”
She turned toward the cooler door and called, “Monte, your Rosalie’s here!”
Then she looked back at me, her eyes full.
“Ma’am, he’s been out here every morning for three months so he can learn to make your anniversary bouquet.”
That was the answer. He’d been learning to arrange flowers for our fiftieth anniversary, and the perfume on his shirts came from working among them. For a second, I couldn’t make the two versions of Monte fit together: the man who had planned a surprise for me and the man who’d snapped at me and hidden $18,000.
Then Monte stepped out from behind the cooler. He had his work shirt on and his patched jacket was still hanging on the hook. He looked at the cart, then at me.
“Rosie,” he said.
I was so relieved there was no other woman that I almost let the rest go. Almost.
“Don’t call it a surprise and expect me to forget the money,” I said.
His mouth tightened. The young woman set the carnations down on the counter and gave us a little room, though she stayed close enough to hear.
“Can we talk somewhere quiet?” Monte asked.
“We can talk right here.”
He looked embarrassed. That didn’t make me feel better. It made me angrier, because embarrassment was not the same thing as an explanation.
“The money’s safe,” he said. “I moved it.”
“Where?”
“Into a certificate. The man who called said the rate was better. I thought I was doing right by us.”
“Then why didn’t you tell me?”
He looked down at the floor. “I wanted the trip to be a surprise. The flowers, too. I was going to bring it all together in the spring.”
“And when I asked where you went?”
“I got scared you’d figure it out.”
“That doesn’t explain why you spoke to me like I was a fool.”
He rubbed the side of his thumb with one finger. It was something he did when he couldn’t find a good answer.
“I was ashamed,” he said. “I thought you’d say I was wasting money on flowers when I should be saving for the trip.”
The young woman glanced at the jacket on the hook. Her face had softened, but she didn’t step in and excuse him. I was grateful for that.
“Rosalie,” she said, “he told me about the postcard on your refrigerator. He showed me a picture of you two from your anniversary. He asked what flowers would last and what would look good on a train trip. I thought you’d know he was here.”
Monte looked at her. “I told you not to say anything.”
“You told me not to ruin the surprise,” she said. “I didn’t know she thought you had another woman.”
I could feel my cheeks warming. I had been so sure I knew what the perfume meant. I also knew I hadn’t invented the lying or the money. The wrong guess was mine. The hurt was still real.
“Did you take the money out of the account for the trip?” I asked him.
“No. It’s in the certificate. I haven’t touched it.”
“Show me.”
“I can show you at home.”
“Then we’re going home now.”
He nodded. Before we left, I thanked the young woman for answering me. She gave me a small, uncertain smile, then picked the carnations up again. Monte’s jacket stayed on the hook. I wanted to take it down and hand it to him. I didn’t.
The drive home was quiet except for the tires on the road. I kept both hands on the wheel. Monte sat beside me with his hands folded, the way he did when he was trying to wait me out. I was too mad to let him.
“You don’t get to tell me you’ll handle it,” I said. “It’s our money.”
“I know.”
“You should’ve told me about the certificate when you opened it.”
“I know.”
“And the flowers aren’t an answer to that.”
He looked out his window. “I know that, too.”
At home, he went to the desk where he kept the bank papers. I stood at the kitchen table beside the postcard and watched him search through the drawer. He found the paperwork and brought it to me, but he didn’t put it in my hand. He laid it down between us.
The account showed the transfer. The money hadn’t vanished into someone’s pocket or gone to a woman. It had been moved into a certificate under Monte’s name. I followed the dates with my finger and read the amount twice. The balance was there.
I felt relief, then a fresh wave of anger at how easily he’d left me to believe the worst. I had been scared of losing our savings and scared of losing my husband, all while he kept the answer tucked in a drawer.
“Who is the financial fella?” I asked.
“Someone who called about the better rate,” Monte said. “He gave me the papers. I signed them.”
“You told me he’d called. You didn’t tell me what you signed.”
“I thought you wouldn’t want to hear about it. You always said I was better with the bank.”
“I said you were better at keeping track of the statements. I didn’t say you could make decisions for both of us and keep them from me.”
He started to answer, then stopped. His eyes stayed on the paper.
I knew that look. He was preparing to say I should’ve asked earlier, or that he was trying to do something nice. Maybe I had let him handle too much for too long. Maybe he had taken my trust as permission. I didn’t want to fight about my part before he faced his.
“I should’ve checked the account in July,” I said. “I didn’t. But you knew I thought that money was in savings.”
“Yes.”
“And you let me think it was gone.”
“Yes.”
That yes landed harder than another excuse would’ve. I pulled out a chair and sat down. My knees were still shaky.
“Call the bank with me,” I said. “I want them to tell us where the money is and what this paper means.”
He picked up the phone. I sat beside him and kept the certificate paperwork in front of me. When someone answered, Monte explained that we were both there and asked them to go through the account with us. He had to repeat a few details. I asked questions, too. No one at the bank acted as if I were foolish for asking. Monte’s hand rested near mine but didn’t touch it.
The person on the phone confirmed the transfer and the balance. It was there, still ours, in the certificate. We could ask about moving it, but there would be terms to consider. I didn’t need to decide that on the spot. What I needed was to know he hadn’t given it away and that he couldn’t make me guess about it again.
After we hung up, Monte looked at the postcard on the refrigerator.
“I still wanted to take you to the Canyon,” he said.
“I still want to go,” I told him. “But I don’t want to be surprised with my own money.”
He nodded. It wasn’t a grand apology. It was the first time that day he’d looked at me without trying to manage my reaction.
“I should’ve told you,” he said.
“Yes,” I said. “You should’ve.”
I wanted to forgive him right then because I loved him and because the thought of the trip still made me happy. But I was nervous to write this part down: for a few weeks, I had wondered whether staying with him was easier than finding out the truth. That fear had made me accept answers I wouldn’t have accepted from anyone else.
I told him I wanted us to look at every statement together from then on. I wanted both of us to know where our savings sat, and I wanted no more decisions made in secret, even if the secret was meant to be a gift. He said yes. I didn’t take that as the end of it. It was a promise he had to keep.
The next morning, I went with him to the bank. We asked for the account information to be set up so I could see it as well. Monte stayed beside me while I checked the balance myself. The money was still there. The trip was still possible, and the choice about what to do with the certificate belonged to both of us.
We drove home past the gas station. Monte didn’t say he was going for coffee with the boys. He said he was going to the grocery store to see if the young woman could show him how to tie the flowers without crushing them.
“Not alone,” I said.
He looked at me, then nodded. “Not alone.”
We went back together. The flower department smelled just as sweet as it had the first time, but my stomach didn’t tighten. The young woman brought out a bucket of flowers and showed Monte how to hold the stems. He fumbled with the paper wrap, and I laughed before I could stop myself.
He looked over at me. “You want to try?”
I took the flowers from him and chose the carnations. We went home with them in a paper sleeve between us. I set them in a glass jar on the kitchen table, next to my reading glasses.