My husband’s girlfriend moved into the rent house across the street from me in April and came over that same week to borrow my step ladder.
“I’m so glad there’s a nice woman on this street,” she said. “My boyfriend works nights, so it’s just me.”
She has no idea I am the one who wrote the check for her deposit, because that check came out of an account I balance every month.
She is thirty-six. She has a hanging basket of ferns and she waves at me every morning.
I have lived on Delaware Street in Poplar Bluff, Missouri since 1989. I raised two boys in that house. I know every dog on this block by name. My husband drives a tanker four nights a week and has since 1998. I do the bills on the fifteenth at this same table with the same green pen. I have paid the propane, the taxes, and his mother’s Medicare supplement out of that account for nineteen years and never once asked him to look at it.
A woman who handles the money in a marriage is trusted right up until she is the last one to know.
She brought me banana bread in May. She sat at my kitchen table and told me her boyfriend lost his wife.
“He’s still not over her,” she said, picking at the edge of her napkin. “He can’t even stay the whole night.”
“That must be hard,” I said.
“I know he needs time. But sometimes I wonder if he’ll ever really move on.”
He cannot stay the whole night because he lives in the house she was sitting in. He goes to work at eleven and comes home at six-thirty in the morning, and on the nights he does not work he is across the street until one or two, and then he is back in our bed by the time I wake up.
I did not know any of this in May. I poured her coffee and told her the banana bread was good.
In March there was a check written for eight hundred dollars to a name I did not recognize, and in the memo line, in his handwriting, it said “Deposit, rental.”
I asked him about it at supper.
“That’s Dale’s boy,” he said, not looking up from his plate. “I cosigned so he could get in somewhere.”
“Dale’s boy?”
“Yeah. Kid’s twenty-two, needed help getting into a place over in Dexter.”
Dale’s boy is twenty-two and lives in Dexter. I let it go, and I have thought about that night every day since.
On the fourth of August she knocked on my door at 7:10 in the evening, crying. Not about him. Her car would not start and she had to be at work at eight.
So I drove her. Twenty-two minutes there and twenty-two minutes back, and she talked the whole way.
“He’s so good to me,” she said. “He’s buying me a washer and dryer. He said I shouldn’t have to go to the laundromat.”
“That’s thoughtful.”
“I know, right? He’s doing everything through his cousin so his kids don’t find out. They’d make his life miserable if they knew he was seeing someone.”
“His cousin?”
“Yeah, he owns an appliance place. He’s getting me a good deal.”
I kept my hands on the wheel and my eyes on the road.
His cousin Ronnie runs an appliance store on Highway 53 and has been my husband’s best friend since the sixth grade. Ronnie’s wife Jeanette and I have gone to the same church for thirty-one years.
I did not sleep that night. At six in the morning I sat down with two years of statements and I read every line the way I read a recipe.
Seven hundred and forty at the appliance store in June, which I had asked about and been told was for our garage freezer. We do not have a garage freezer.
Three hundred at a furniture place in Sikeston in May.
Eight hundred for a deposit in March to a landlord I now wave at.
There were other things. Smaller things. A charge at a florist I had never heard of. Two transactions at a restaurant we have never been to together. It was all there, and I had signed off on it every month, and I had believed him every time.
On the eleventh of August I drove to Ronnie’s store at 9:05 in the morning. Jeanette was at the front counter doing the books, which she does on Mondays.
She looked up and her whole face changed color, and that is when I knew she knew.
“Denise,” she said.
“Jeanette.”
“Don’t.”
I set the receipt on the counter between us. “I’ve got a receipt here with your store’s name on it and my husband’s account paying for it.”
She put her pen down and looked at the door to the back where Ronnie was.
“How long have you known?” I said.
She folded her hands on top of the ledger. “Since Christmas.”
“Christmas.”
“Denise, I, “
“You’ve known since Christmas and you never said a word.”
“It wasn’t my place.” Her voice broke. “Ronnie told me to stay out of it.”
“We go to the same church, Jeanette. We’ve sat in the same pew for thirty-one years.”
She started to cry, and I did not comfort her. I stood there and waited until she could look at me again.
“There’s something else,” she said. “And if I tell you, Ronnie will never forgive me, and I’m going to tell you anyway.”
“Tell me.”
Jeanette came around that counter and took both of my hands.
“He bought the house,” she said. “Not just the deposit. He bought it outright in February. Ronnie helped him set up the LLC so your name wouldn’t be on anything. It’s in his name and some corporation filing, but the money came from your joint account in pieces. He’s been pulling it for months.”
I did not say anything. There was nothing to say that was big enough.
“The girlfriend doesn’t even pay rent,” Jeanette said. “She thinks she does, but he just puts the checks in a drawer. Ronnie saw them last time he was over there helping install the washer.”
The washer I paid for. In the house I paid for. For the woman who waved at me every morning and thought I was nice.
I drove home and I sat at the kitchen table with the green pen and I made a list. Every account. Every password. Every automatic payment. I called the propane company and took my name off the service authorization. I called the tax assessor and requested copies of every property deed in his name. I called a lawyer I went to high school with and made an appointment for Monday.
When he came home at six-thirty on the twelfth I was still at that table.
“You’re up early,” he said.
“Sit down.”
“I need to get some sleep, “
“Sit down.”
He sat. He looked at the papers I had laid out between us and his face went careful and blank.
“Jeanette told me about the house,” I said.
“Denise, “
“Don’t. I know about the deposit. I know about the furniture and the washer and the freezer that doesn’t exist. I know you bought the place in February and I know she doesn’t actually pay rent.”
He opened his mouth and closed it again.
“I want to know when you were planning to tell me,” I said. “Or if you were ever planning to tell me at all.”
“It’s not what you think.”
“Then what is it?”
He looked at his hands. “I don’t know.”
“You don’t know.”
“It just happened. I didn’t mean for it to, “
“You bought a house, Michael. You didn’t trip and fall into a mortgage. You forged my signature on documents and you moved her in across the street from me and you let me wave at her like an idiot.”
“I never forged anything. It’s an LLC. Your name’s not on it because it’s a business property.”
“Funded with money from our joint account that I manage.”
He did not have an answer for that.
“She brought me banana bread,” I said. “She sat in this kitchen and told me her boyfriend couldn’t stay the night because he wasn’t over his dead wife.”
“I never said you were dead.”
“You let her believe it. You let her think you were some grieving widower instead of a man who goes home to his real wife every morning.”
He put his head in his hands. “I’ll sell the house. I’ll end it. Just don’t, “
“Don’t what? Don’t leave? Don’t take half of everything you’ve been stealing from me for months?”
“It’s not stealing if it’s our money.”
I stood up. I had been sitting for so long my legs were stiff.
“I’ve been managing our money for nineteen years,” I said. “I paid for your mother’s Medicare. I paid for both boys to finish school. I paid the taxes on this house and the propane and the insurance and every utility bill and I never asked you to look at a single statement because I thought we were partners.”
“We are, “
“No. We were. You made sure of that when you signed the deed.”
I went upstairs and I packed a bag, and when I came back down he was still sitting at the table.
“Where are you going?” he said.
“My sister’s. You can stay here or you can stay across the street, I don’t care anymore. But when you get the papers from my lawyer, you’re going to sign them.”
“Denise, please, “
“I drove her to work, Michael. I sat in the car and listened to her talk about how good you are to her, and I smiled and I drove her twenty-two minutes there and twenty-two minutes back, and the whole time I knew. Do you understand that? I knew, and I still had to be nice.”
He did not say anything.
I picked up my bag and walked out the door. She was in her front yard watering the ferns, and when she saw me she waved. I did not wave back.
I stayed at my sister’s house in Cape Girardeau for three weeks. My lawyer filed in the third week of August. We were separated by October and divorced by January. The house on Delaware Street sold and I bought a condo in town with my half. He kept the rental property, which is what he wanted all along, and last I heard she still lives there and still does not pay rent.
Ronnie’s store closed in March. I do not know if that had anything to do with Jeanette finally telling the truth, but I know they separated around the same time my papers were filed. Jeanette still goes to our church, and we still sit in the same pew, and now when we look at each other we both know the cost of waiting too long to say the true thing.
I do not drive down Delaware Street anymore. I do not need to see the house I paid for or the woman who still thinks she got a love story.
I got the bank statements and the green pen and nineteen years of knowledge about where every penny went. That turned out to be worth more than I thought.