My daughter tore up a letter from the boy I almost married in 1969, saying he only wanted my house. She dropped the pieces in my kitchen trash. “Mama, you’re seventy-four. Don’t be a fool.” I didn’t fuss at her. That night I taped every piece back together at my kitchen table. Two days later I was standing on his porch four hours away, holding that letter, when the door opened and…

My name is Lavonne. Folks at church call me Vonnie. I was the school librarian in Baxley, Georgia, for thirty-eight years. I’m seventy-four. My husband, Wilfred, has been gone six years.

He was a good, steady man, and I never once told him about Asa Kimbrough. Asa was the boy I loved when I was seventeen. He had a crooked tooth and a green Chevy and he sang in the car with the windows down.

In the spring of 1969 he got his draft notice, and the night before he left, he gave me a little ring with a chip of a stone in it.

“When I get home, Vonnie, we’re doing it right,” he said. “Church and all.”

I wrote him every week for ten months. Then one Saturday his mama drove out to our house. She stood on our porch and handed me a shoebox with every letter I’d ever sent him.

“He married a girl over there in Germany,” she said. “He doesn’t want to hear from you.”

I gave her back the ring right there on the porch. I cried till Christmas. The next fall I married Wilfred, and I made myself stop thinking about it.

Fifty-six years I made myself stop. Two weeks ago a letter came to my house in a long white envelope. The handwriting stopped my heart. Big and slanted, the same as on the back of a picture I’d thrown away in 1970.

I sat down right there at the mailbox. Dear Vonnie, it said. I found your name in the church directory your granddaughter put on the internet. I’ve thought about you every day for fifty-seven years.

I didn’t get any further, because my daughter pulled into the drive. Kerri is forty-nine, and she drops by every afternoon to check on me. She took one look at my face and snatched that letter right out of my hand.

She read it standing in my kitchen, and her mouth got tighter and tighter.

“Mama, who is this man?”

“Somebody I knew before your daddy.”

“He says he’s a widower. He says he’s alone in a big house.”

“That’s what it says, honey.”

“Mama, this is how they do it,” she said. “They find lonely widows and they write them sweet letters.”

“He’s not like that.”

“You don’t know what he’s like. You haven’t seen him in sixty years.”

Then she tore it in half. And in half again. And again. She dropped the pieces in my kitchen trash on top of the coffee grounds.

“Mama, you’re seventy-four. Don’t be a fool.”

“That was mine,” I said.

“He only wants your house,” she said. “Somebody has to look out for you.”

And she kissed my cheek like she’d done me a favor, and she left. I stood there a long time looking at that trash can. Maybe she was right.

Maybe I was a silly old woman who’d lost her good sense over one sweet line. I’ve read about those men in the paper, same as anybody. But it was his handwriting.

That night, after the news, I put on my reading glasses and dug every scrap out of the coffee grounds. I wiped them off on a dish towel and laid them on my kitchen table like a puzzle. It took me till one in the morning and most of a roll of Scotch tape.

Then I read the whole thing. He never married any girl in Germany. He’d come home in 1970 and gone straight to my mama’s house, and my mama told him I’d already married Wilfred.

I hadn’t. Not for months yet. He said his own mama cried for a week after that and never told him why. He married in 1975. Forty-six years. She passed in 2021.

And then, near the bottom, one line that I read so many times the tape started to come up. I kept the ring, Vonnie. I don’t know why. I guess I knew. His address was at the bottom. Greenwood, South Carolina. Four hours away.

I didn’t sleep that night, or the next one. Then I called Kerri.

“I’m going to see him,” I said.

“Mama, if you go, don’t call me crying when he cleans you out.”

“I won’t,” I said, and I meant it.

I put on my good blue dress and my late mama’s brooch, and I drove that four hours alone.

I hadn’t driven on an interstate since Wilfred’s surgery. I sang in the car with the windows down, and I cried, and I sang some more.

His house was a little brick one with a porch swing and a green Chevy truck in the drive. I sat in my car for twenty minutes trying to make my legs work. Then I walked up those steps, still holding the taped-up letter, and knocked.

I heard a cane on a wood floor, slow, coming closer. The door opened, and there he was, holding the little ring box. His hair had gone white, and one hand gripped the cane I’d heard against the floor. He looked at the letter in my hand, then at my face.

“Vonnie. You came.”

I had rehearsed things to say during the drive. I’d forgotten every one of them.

“I came,” I said. “I hope I’m not too late.”

He stepped back from the door. “Come in before we do this out here.”

I crossed his threshold on legs that still felt uncertain. The box was small and worn at the corners. He held it carefully, like he’d carried it for a long time.

“I kept it,” he said.

I touched the lid with one finger. “You really did.”

He opened it. The little ring was inside, its stone still chipped. I started crying, which embarrassed me, but Asa didn’t look away or try to hurry me.

“May I?” he asked.

I nodded, and he took my hand. The ring fit loosely, but it was the same ring. For a second, I was seventeen again, and then I was myself, standing in the entryway of a man’s house with a life behind me that I wouldn’t trade.

“I thought you were married,” I said.

His face changed. “I thought you were.”

We sat at his kitchen table. I kept the taped-up letter between us, and Asa set the ring box beside it. His coffee cup had a brown mark around the rim. I noticed it because I needed something ordinary to look at while my whole life rearranged itself.

“Your mama told me you’d married Wilfred,” he said. “I came home in 1970 and went straight to your house. She said you were already his wife.”

“I wasn’t. Not then.”

“I asked her if I could see you. She said no. Said you were settled and happy, and I ought to leave you alone.”

I looked down at the tape crossing the letter. “My mama told me you’d married a girl in Germany.”

“I never married in Germany. I wasn’t even close to getting married then.”

I felt angry first, and then sad, and then angry again. Our mothers had made two short decisions for us, and we’d spent years living as if those decisions were the truth.

“What did your mama say when you asked about me?” I asked.

Asa rubbed his thumb along the cane handle. “She told me later she’d made it up. She thought I’d go looking for you, and you’d wait on me instead of building a life. She said she was trying to spare you both.”

“By telling me you didn’t want to hear from me?”

He looked ashamed. “That’s what she told you?”

“Yes.”

“I’m sorry, Vonnie. I didn’t know.”

He hadn’t known. I could see that he meant it, but meaning it didn’t hand back the time. I was too old to pretend that part didn’t hurt.

“My mama said you were married,” I told him. “I think she wanted me to stop hoping. She probably thought she was protecting me, too.”

“Did she ever tell you she saw me?”

“No.”

We sat with that for a while. I thought about Wilfred, and I said his name aloud because he belonged in the room with the truth.

“I loved my husband,” I said. “He was good to me. I won’t make him a footnote because you came back.”

Asa nodded. “I wouldn’t ask you to.”

That answer mattered. I’d been afraid he would want me to pick up exactly where we’d stopped, as if nothing else had happened. He didn’t ask me to erase a single year.

“I should tell you something,” I said. “I almost didn’t come. My daughter thinks you wrote because I have a house.”

“I don’t want your house.”

The words came out plain and quick. He looked almost offended that I’d had to ask, then softened when he saw my face.

“I have my own home,” he said. “I wrote because I wanted to know if you were alive and well. I wanted to tell you I never stopped thinking about you.”

I had been ready for a slick answer. I had been ready to find a man who saw an old woman alone and a house worth taking. Instead, Asa sat across from me with his cane against the table and the ring box between us.

“I don’t know what I’m supposed to do with this,” I said.

“You don’t have to decide today.”

That surprised me. “You waited this long.”

“I did. I can wait until you’ve had supper.”

A laugh slipped out of me, though my eyes were wet. It was the first time I’d laughed all day. Asa smiled, and I recognized the crooked tooth from the boy who used to sing with the car windows down. It was still there, though the rest of him had changed.

I stayed long enough to hear about his wife. He spoke of her with kindness, and I was glad. She’d been his companion for forty-six years. I asked about his house, and he told me how much he liked the porch swing. He asked about Baxley and my work at the school library, and I told him I’d spent thirty-eight years putting books back where children could find them.

“Did you keep singing?” he asked.

“Mostly in the car.”

“Good place for it.”

I had planned to drive straight home. Instead, I called Kerri from my car before I pulled out of his driveway.

“Did he ask for money?” she said when she answered.

“No. He showed me the ring.”

There was a pause. “What ring?”

“The one he gave me before he left in 1969. He kept it.”

Kerri didn’t answer right away. I looked through the windshield at Asa’s little brick house and the green Chevy truck in the drive.

“He says he never married in Germany,” I said. “He came home in 1970. He went to Grandma’s house, and she told him I’d married Wilfred.”

“I don’t understand.”

“Neither do I. Your grandma told me he’d married someone in Germany. Asa says his mother told him later she made that up because she thought he’d come looking for me.”

“That’s awful,” Kerri said.

“Yes. It is.”

I could hear her breathing. I knew what she’d been afraid of. She checked on me every afternoon because she loved me, and because she’d seen enough sad stories to worry that a lonely person might believe the wrong one.

“I thought I was looking out for you,” she said.

“I know you did. But you tore up something that belonged to me.”

“I know, Mama.”

“You don’t get to decide I’m a fool because I’m seventy-four.”

She started to say something, then stopped. “I’m sorry.”

“I’m not ready to say it’s all right.”

“I understand.”

I didn’t want to punish her. I wanted her to know that she’d hurt me, and that I wasn’t going to pretend it hadn’t happened just to make the call easier.

“I’m going to come home,” I said. “I’ll call you tomorrow.”

“Okay. Please drive safe.”

“I will.”

The next afternoon, Kerri came by as usual. She brought groceries and put the milk away before she took off her coat. She stood in my kitchen looking at the trash can, like she expected to see the scraps there.

“I should have asked you before I took it,” she said.

“Yes.”

“I got scared. Those letters in the paper, the stories about people losing their savings. I looked at you and thought you were about to get hurt.”

“I was scared, too,” I said. “I just didn’t want you to choose for me.”

She sat down at the table. “Can I meet him?”

I hadn’t expected her to ask so soon. I wanted to say no and keep the two parts of my life apart. I also knew she’d keep worrying unless she saw him for herself.

“If Asa wants that,” I said. “And you’ll let him speak for himself.”

“I will.”

I called Asa while Kerri was still there. He said she was welcome to come, and we made a plan for the following week. I told Kerri we’d go together. I didn’t want her driving alone, and I wanted to be beside her when they met.

On the drive to his house, Kerri kept her hands folded in her lap. She didn’t ask me if I was sure. I was grateful for that.

Asa opened the door with his cane in one hand. The ring box wasn’t with him this time. He looked at Kerri first and then at me.

“You must be Kerri,” he said.

“I am.” She swallowed. “I’m sorry I judged you before I met you.”

Asa glanced at me. “You were trying to protect your mother.”

“I was,” Kerri said. “But I took her letter. I had no right to do that.”

She didn’t make excuses. Her eyes were wet, and she looked uncomfortable saying it, which made me believe her.

“Thank you for saying so,” Asa told her. “I can see why you worried. I only wish you could’ve read the whole letter before it went in the trash.”

Kerri gave a small, embarrassed smile. “I wish I had.”

We sat on the porch. Asa told her what he’d told me about the two mothers, and Kerri listened without interrupting. When he finished, she shook her head.

“They both thought they were helping,” she said.

“They did what they thought was best,” I said. “It still cost us something.”

Kerri looked at me. “I’m sorry, Mama.”

This time I reached across and squeezed her hand. I was still hurt, but I could feel her trying to make things right. That counted for something.

After that, Asa and I started talking on the phone. At first, we kept the calls short. There was too much to catch up on, and I didn’t want the past to hurry me into anything. We spoke about ordinary things: what he’d had for breakfast, whether the rain had started, how often I still visited the library even though I’d retired.

Some nights we talked for an hour. Some nights we just said good night. It felt good to hear his voice, and strange to admit how much I’d missed a voice I hadn’t heard in fifty-six years.

I told Kerri when I was going to see him. I didn’t ask her permission. She stopped checking my face for signs that I’d been tricked and started asking what we’d talked about.

One evening, Asa asked if I’d consider marrying him.

He didn’t bring it up as a grand surprise. We were sitting at his kitchen table, and he had the ring box beside his cup.

“I know we’re not seventeen,” he said. “I know we’ve both had whole lives since then. I still want to spend what time we have together, if you do.”

I let the question sit for a day. I thought about Wilfred, about the years we’d shared, and about how much I still missed him. Loving Asa wouldn’t take that love away. It would be another thing, not a replacement.

When I called Asa the next day, I told him yes.

I called Kerri after that. I expected her to worry again, but she was quiet for a moment and then said, “I’m glad you’re choosing this because you want it.”

“That’s why.”

“Then I’ll be there.”

We married at the courthouse in spring. Kerri stood beside me, and Asa held the ring box in his palm until I reached for the ring. The clerk smiled when Asa fumbled with it, and he laughed at himself.

“My hands used to be steadier,” he said.

“They were never that steady,” I told him.

Kerri laughed, too. I looked at her and saw the girl who used to visit me after school, and the grown woman who’d tried to protect me badly, and the daughter who came back to say she was sorry. I was glad she stood there with us.

The house stayed mine. Asa never asked for it, and I never had to wonder what he wanted when he called. We made our own choices, at our own pace.

The first evening he came to my house after we married, I set out two cups of coffee. He sat at my kitchen table and put the ring box beside his cup. I turned the crooked picture on the wall straight, and he laughed when it tilted again.

amomana

amomana

6476 articles published