My husband’s ex flirted with him right in front of me at his 60th high school reunion, so I gave her a little gift that sent her straight for the exit. I’m eighty years old, and Walter and I have been married for fifty-eight years. If another woman wants him, I hope she likes snoring, football, and finding dentures in places where dentures have no business being.
The reunion was last Saturday. It had been postponed twice because half the committee needed hip replacements, so Walter had been looking forward to it for a while. In the weeks before it finally happened, he brought up the shrimp cocktail more than once. He wore his good cardigan, and I went with him knowing that the evening would involve old stories, familiar faces, and quite possibly a longer visit than I would choose for myself.
That’s how I am about reunions. I treat them like dental appointments. I show up, smile, nod, and try to leave before anyone brings up a colonoscopy. Walter likes going more than I do. He enjoys hearing what people remember and talking about the years they shared. I can enjoy that for him without pretending that an evening of introductions and old school stories is my favorite way to spend a Saturday.
We’ve been married for fifty-eight years, which is long enough for the little things to become part of the landscape.
Walter snores. He watches football. His dentures occasionally turn up somewhere they have no business being, and I have learned that it’s easier to help find them than to ask how they got there in the first place.
I love him in the ordinary, familiar way of a woman who has spent most of her adult life beside the same man. I know his habits, including the ones that try my patience. He knows mine too. We can have a whole conversation with a look, or disagree about something small and get over it before the day is out. That kind of life doesn’t look dramatic from the outside, but it was mine, and I was proud of it.
Walter had been talking about the reunion as the date got closer. He was glad it was finally happening after two postponements. The reason for the delays was hard to argue with. Half the committee needed hip replacements, and people have to do what they have to do. It still meant Walter had waited longer than he expected to see the people he remembered.
He also had his mind on the food. For three weeks, the shrimp cocktail had kept coming up. I don’t mean that he spoke about nothing else. He talked about the reunion itself. But if there was a pause, or if he wanted to know what to expect, the shrimp came back into the conversation. I teased him about it because I’d heard enough to know where his priorities were.
He took extra care with his good cardigan. He had a way of checking that everything was in order before leaving. I watched him get ready and felt glad that he was looking forward to something. I wasn’t going to spoil that by making the evening about how I felt about reunions or about one name on a guest list.
I’d seen Marilyn’s name two weeks earlier. That was the first time the evening began to feel different to me. Walter had mentioned her before, though never as if there were any present-day story attached to the name. She had been his high school girlfriend and his senior prom date. In fifty-eight years he had accidentally mentioned her three times, and twice he had done it in his sleep.
I had heard she’d recently buried her fifth husband and was already interviewing candidates for number six. That was what I knew. It was enough to make me picture her as someone who liked an audience, but I didn’t know what she would do when she arrived, and I wasn’t interested in making up a fight ahead of time.
I noticed the name on the list, put it aside, and went on with my day. Walter hadn’t done anything wrong. He’d told me about Marilyn over the years, and he hadn’t kept some secret life tucked away from me. A name from his past wasn’t a reason to punish him for something he hadn’t done.
Still, I prepared a little gift. I found a small pink gift bag and put tissue paper and a ribbon with it. Then I tucked it into my handbag. I knew Marilyn would be at the reunion, and I thought it was wise to have the bag ready in case the evening turned in a direction I didn’t like.
I didn’t tell Walter what was in the bag. I didn’t want to explain my idea before I knew whether I would need it. He would probably have wanted to know why I was bringing a gift to the reunion, and then I would have had to tell him. I might have changed my mind, or he might have talked me out of it without even trying. So I kept it to myself.
I wasn’t sure I would use it. That’s the truth. I carried it because I could, and because I had a feeling Marilyn might make herself the center of the evening. I didn’t know whether she would be friendly, boastful, or simply pleased to see an old classmate. I didn’t know whether she would even speak to me. I was prepared for a possibility, not certain of an outcome.
The reunion itself started without any trouble. There were people there who had once known Walter as a young man, people whose faces he recognized, and people whose names took a moment to come back. I stayed with him and followed his lead. Sometimes the best way to be a good companion is to listen while the person you came with gets to have the conversation he came for.
I don’t have to enjoy every part of an evening to be glad Walter is enjoying it. He had waited through two postponements, and he was happy to finally be there. I could see that. He had his good cardigan on, and he was ready to catch up with people he hadn’t seen in a long time.
As for me, I did what I usually do at gatherings like that. I smiled when someone spoke to us. I listened to the stories. I let Walter have the room to be remembered as he had been, not just as the man who snores and watches football beside me now. I was proud to be there with him, even if I was also keeping one eye on the door.
The names and memories belonged to a time before I knew Walter. There’s nothing strange about that. We all came into one another’s lives after some parts of our stories had already happened. His high school years were his, and I could hear about them without feeling threatened by every person who had once been important to him.
Marilyn was different only because I knew she had once been his girlfriend. That didn’t make her my enemy. It did mean I noticed when I saw her name on the guest list, and it meant I paid attention when she walked in.
The doors opened, and there she was.
She wore a sequined dress. Her silver hair was set like a helmet, and she had red lipstick on. Her perfume seemed to arrive before she did. It was a strong entrance, the sort that made people notice her even before she reached the middle of the room.
Marilyn looked straight at Walter and crossed toward him. She looked right past me. I was standing there beside my husband, close enough to hear every word, and she acted as if I were a coat rack. I felt the sting of it at once. It was such a small, deliberate insult, and I could tell she meant me to notice.
Then she took both of Walter’s hands.
“Walter!” she said. “I just knew we’d meet again.”
She held on to him as she spoke. I watched his face. He squinted at her for a long moment, trying to recognize her. I knew that look. He was searching his memory, not putting on some act to encourage her.
A smart man might have stepped back. Walter didn’t. He was still working out who she was, and the rest of us had already moved ahead to the part where she was flirting with him. I felt my annoyance rise, but I also saw how little of the moment he understood.
“Marilyn?” he asked. Then he said, “Do you know where they’re hiding the shrimp?”
Bless his heart. He had greeted the woman who had just taken his hands by asking for the food. I nearly laughed, and I was grateful for the question. It was so completely Walter that for a second it cut through my irritation.
Marilyn gave a high, tinkling giggle. It was the kind of sound that made me wonder how anyone kept a straight face after sixty. She was still holding his attention, and now she was making sure the whole exchange sounded like a private joke.
“Still so modest,” she said. “Save me a dance, handsome.”
Walter didn’t seem to know what to do with that. His eyes moved from her face to mine, then back again. He wasn’t smiling the way a man smiles when he is pleased with someone’s attention. He looked confused. I could tell he was trying to be polite, but I could also see he hadn’t caught the meaning of her words.
I didn’t blame Walter for missing it. He had come to see people from school and eat shrimp. He had not walked into the room expecting his old girlfriend to grab his hands and ask for a dance. He had never given me a reason to believe he was waiting for Marilyn to come back into his life.
I did blame Marilyn for ignoring me. She had the chance to greet both of us. She could have said hello to Walter, then turned and introduced herself to me. Instead, she behaved as if I were an obstacle she could leave standing at the edge of the conversation.
I was standing right there. It wasn’t possible to mistake me for someone who had wandered into the middle of their reunion by accident. I had arrived with Walter, and I was beside him when she took his hands. Her choice to act as if I didn’t exist was plain.
Then Marilyn turned to me. She had a smile that looked friendly from a distance and sharp up close.
“And you must be… his sister?”
For half a second, I could only look at her. My face warmed, and my stomach tightened. I could have answered her in a way that would have made the people nearby pay attention. I could have made it clear that she had insulted me, that I was Walter’s wife, and that she ought to stop holding his hands.
The words were right there. I could feel them. But I didn’t want to make a scene just because Marilyn had gone looking for one. I had spent enough of my life learning that if you respond to every slight with the sharpest thing you can say, the person who started it gets to pretend you were the problem.
That didn’t mean I was going to swallow the insult and smile as if it were a compliment. I was furious. I was also embarrassed, though I didn’t like admitting that. I felt the eyes of the people nearby, and I knew they had heard her. Her little question had made my marriage sound like something she could erase with a smile.
Fifty-eight years of marriage teaches a woman many things. How to count to ten. How to keep her face straight. And exactly when to open her handbag.
Women my age don’t carry purses. We carry survival kits. Mine had what I needed for an evening out, along with the small pink gift bag I’d prepared. I felt the ribbon under my hand and remembered the reason I’d brought it. I had been hoping not to need it. Now I was glad it was there.
I looked at Walter. He still seemed bewildered. He had been made part of a flirtation he hadn’t asked for, and he couldn’t make sense of why Marilyn was now calling me his sister. I wanted to spare him from being pulled any farther into it.
I also wanted Marilyn to understand that she couldn’t dismiss me and then expect me to stand there graciously while she made plans to dance with my husband. I could have answered her directly. I could have told her my relationship to Walter. She already knew, or she had enough information in front of her to guess. But I wasn’t going to give her the argument she seemed to be offering.
I reached into my handbag and brought out the pink bag.
“Marilyn, dear,” I said. “Before you two dance, I’ve got a little gift for you. Something to remember Walter by.”
The words came out sweetly. I kept my voice even. It took effort. I didn’t want it to sound like I was shouting, and I didn’t want to say more than I needed to. She had asked whether I was Walter’s sister, and I was answering her in the only way I chose to answer.
Walter looked at me and then at Marilyn. He didn’t ask what I was doing. He was still trying to understand what had happened between the woman who had taken his hands and the woman who had been standing beside him the whole time.
Marilyn looked at the bag. Her eyebrows shot up. She reached for it, and I let her take it. The bag was small, pink, and dressed up with tissue paper and a ribbon. In her hands, it looked like a thoughtful present. She took it with a smug little smile, as if I had just handed her a trophy.
“For me?” she said. “How thoughtful!”
I kept my own face pleasant. If I had smiled too broadly, she might have known something was coming. If I had looked angry, she might have tried to turn the exchange around and say I was being rude. I wanted her to open the bag when she was ready. That was why I hadn’t told her what to expect.
“Open it when you’re ready, dear,” I said. “You’ll need it.”
She held the bag and glanced at me. I watched her look from the ribbon to my face. I couldn’t tell what she thought I had given her. It was clear she believed the gift was a gesture of kindness, or at least something she could accept in front of the people around us and turn into a little victory.
She had wanted a dance with Walter. She had made a show of taking his hands, calling him handsome, and asking for a dance. Then she had turned to me and suggested I was his sister. It was hard to see how she could have thought I would simply enjoy watching her do all that.
I didn’t say that to her. I didn’t need to. I had already handed her the bag, and the way she responded to what she found inside would tell me more than another exchange of insults could. I waited while she decided whether to open it there or take it with her.
Marilyn’s fingers moved to the tissue paper. She looked at Walter once more. He was standing there, still puzzled. He wasn’t trying to encourage her. He wasn’t even sure what she was doing. His attention had shifted from the shrimp to the strange turn the conversation had taken, but he still didn’t have the explanation.
Marilyn looked inside.
Her smug smile vanished. She turned as pale as the tablecloth.
I didn’t need to ask whether the gift had surprised her. I could see that it had. A minute earlier, she had looked pleased with herself. Now her face had changed, and she had stopped acting as if the evening belonged to her.
I won’t pretend I felt sorry for her right away. I had been standing beside my husband while she treated me as if I weren’t there. Then she had asked if I was his sister. I was hurt, and I was angry. Watching that smile disappear was a relief I had not expected to feel so strongly.
At the same time, I didn’t want the whole room to turn into a public argument. I didn’t raise my voice or ask the people around us to judge who had done what. I gave her the gift and let her look inside. What she did after that was up to her.
She stared into the bag again. Then she looked at me. The expression on her face wasn’t the smug one she had worn when she took it. Her posture had changed too. The flirtation, the invitation to dance, and the little insult about my being Walter’s sister seemed to have fallen away.
I didn’t tell her to leave. I didn’t have to. Five minutes later, she was heading straight for the exit.
She carried the small pink bag with her. She didn’t stop to ask Walter for a dance. She didn’t turn back to explain herself to me. She simply walked toward the door, leaving the reunion behind.
I watched her go, still angry about what she had said. I was also relieved. I hadn’t wanted to spend the rest of the evening standing beside a woman who had decided to treat me like a piece of furniture while she flirted with my husband.
Walter watched her leave too. His expression was completely bewildered. He had seen Marilyn come in, grab his hands, and ask for a dance. Then he had seen me give her a gift and watched her head for the exit. He was missing the middle of the story, and he looked to me for it.
He turned toward me.
“Birdie,” he said, “what on earth did you put in that bag?”