A new widow at our church told me she’d have my husband by Thanksgiving, and he just grinned. “You’ve had him long enough, hon. Share.” After that, she brought him a pie every Sunday, and he ate every crumb. I didn’t make a scene.
My name’s Claudette. I poured coffee at a truck stop off the freeway for thirty-one years, so I know when a man is being flirted with. I know when the woman doing it is enjoying herself, too. Trudy was new to our church, and she wore red lipstick to the September potluck.
She had lost her husband in the spring and moved up to Reno to be near her daughter. I knew that much. We were having one of those welcome gatherings where everybody brought a dish and introductions got repeated over the hum of the coffee urn. I was standing in line with my green chile casserole when Trudy slid in beside Myles.
She looked right at me.
“You’ve had him long enough, hon. Share.”
Then she laughed and said she’d have him by Thanksgiving. Myles grinned like a boy who’d found a dollar. We’d been married thirty-eight years, and I knew that grin. At home he still moved the salt toward me before I asked, and he knew I liked my coffee strong. That day, though, he seemed pleased to have caught somebody’s eye.
I felt my face go hot.
“Myles,” I said.
“Oh, Claud, she’s kidding,” he said. “Lighten up.”
I wanted to say something sharp. I didn’t. I picked up my casserole and went to find a place at the table, mad at him and embarrassed that the people nearby had heard. Trudy sat down close to him anyway.
She wasn’t kidding, or at least she kept acting as if the joke belonged to her.
The next Sunday she brought a cherry pie with a lattice top. Myles ate the first slice in the church parking lot, every crumb, while Trudy stood there smiling. The Sunday after that, she brought peach. Then she needed her kitchen sink looked at. Then her porch light.
Myles had a way of hearing a request as if it were a compliment. He’d been putting off our kitchen sink for four years. I had a bucket under it, and I emptied it when I remembered. Trudy only had to ask once.
One evening, right at supper, our landline rang. I still keep a landline, and I don’t care what anybody says about it. I had one hand on a dish towel and the other on the receiver when Trudy asked for Myles.
“Is Myles there, hon? My garbage disposal’s making that noise again.”
“Have you tried turning it off?” I said.
She laughed as if I were the cute one.
“Put him on, would you?”
Myles took the phone into the hall. He talked to her for twenty minutes about a disposal. I could hear him laughing now and then while I sat at the kitchen table with my supper getting cold.
When he came back, he said she was a widow and it was the Christian thing to do.
“Then be a Christian at home and fix that sink,” I said.
He laughed, picked up his pie plate, and carried it out to the car. I watched him go. I was so angry I could barely trust myself to speak, and I was ashamed that I had started keeping score. I kept doing it anyway.
All fall, he went over to Trudy’s on Tuesdays with his toolbox, whistling. If I asked what he’d done, he said something small. If I asked when he’d do the sink at home, he’d say soon. I didn’t sleep well. At sixty-four, I started wondering if Myles wanted Trudy more than he wanted me, and I hate admitting I let myself go there.
Maybe I was the fool. Maybe I had let myself go, and she was pretty, and he was tired of me. Those thoughts came at night, when the house was quiet and there was nothing to distract me from them.
Then one evening my sister called. She’d been married to a flirt for twenty years herself, so she knew how the excuses sounded.
“Claudette,” she said, “do you want to fight her, or do you want to win?”
“Win,” I said.
“Then quit getting mad and get funny.”
I didn’t think I was funny. I was hurt and furious, and I’d been treating Myles like a man who didn’t know what he was doing. The truth was, he knew enough to enjoy the attention. But my sister had given me something better than another argument, so I decided to try it.
The next Sunday, Trudy came by our pew with a coconut cream pie.
“For your husband,” she said. “Since nobody at home bakes for him.”
Myles looked pleased. I smiled at her as if she’d brought me roses.
“Trudy, you’re so good to him,” I said. “I’m going to get you a little something for Thanksgiving. Just from me.”
She looked surprised. Myles looked happy, the big dummy.
That week, I ran into Trudy at the gas station. She winked at me over the top of her shopping basket.
“Thanksgiving’s coming, Claudette. Tick tock.”
I smiled so hard my cheeks hurt. On the drive home, Myles said it was nicer when I was sweet.
“Real nice,” I said.
For three weeks I worked on the present out in the garage, where Myles never went. I got the biggest box Raley’s had out back. I bought red paper, gold ribbon, and a bow the size of a dinner plate. I sat on an old lawn chair with a cup of decaf and made my little gift.
It was a sign and a notebook. I wrote down the pies and the jobs I knew about, then painted the sign by hand. Nothing fancy. The sign read, “Myles’s Handy Service. Payment accepted in pie.” I wasn’t going to hide what it was. I wanted Trudy to see the joke, and I wanted Myles to hear what I had been swallowing for weeks.
He saw the box once when he came into the garage for something.
“What’s in that?” he asked.
“Trudy’s present.”
He shook his head at me.
“You make a scene at church, Claudette, and nobody’ll sit with you again. I mean it.”
Funny, him worrying about scenes. He hadn’t worried about the ones he was making at home, or about how it felt to hear Trudy say she’d have him.
“It’s a gift, Myles,” I said. “Gifts aren’t scenes.”
The church Thanksgiving supper was in the fellowship hall the next Sunday. Long tables, paper turkeys, and the good coffee urn. Trudy wore a sweater the color of a fire truck. She had saved Myles the end seat right next to her.
“Myles, I saved you a spot,” she called across the room.
He went.
When the pastor finished the blessing, I stood with the big red box. I could see people looking up from their plates. I could also see Myles chewing like he hoped nobody would ask him anything.
“Before we eat, you guys,” I said, “I’ve got a little something for Trudy.”
Everybody turned in their folding chairs. Trudy put a hand on her chest.
“Oh, Claudette. You shouldn’t have.”
“Oh, I really should have,” I said.
I set the box right in her lap. Myles stopped chewing. The pastor’s wife leaned forward in her chair. Trudy laughed and tugged on the gold ribbon. The bow came off in her hands. She lifted the lid, and the whole fellowship hall looked down into that box at a hand-painted sign and a notebook with the pies and repairs written inside.
The sign said, “Myles’s Handy Service. Payment accepted in pie.”
The notebook listed the cherry pie beside her garbage disposal, the peach pie beside her porch light, and the coconut cream pie beside the kitchen sink she had asked him to look at. I had written the jobs down because I wanted to be accurate. There was nothing hidden in it. I had put the joke where everyone could see it.
For a second, nobody spoke. Then the pastor’s wife covered her mouth, and somebody down the table let out a laugh they tried to turn into a cough.
Trudy’s smile slipped. She looked into the box again, then up at me.
“That’s what you think this is?” she asked.
“I think you’ve been bringing my husband pies and asking him to fix your house,” I said. “And I think you told me you’d have him by Thanksgiving.”
Myles set down his fork. He was no longer grinning.
“Claudette, not here.”
“You said you were worried I’d make a scene,” I told him. “This is the first time you’ve looked worried about what you did.”
The pastor’s wife sat back. Trudy held the notebook in both hands, and I could see the paper shaking a little. She wasn’t the only one who looked uncomfortable. I was, too. My hands felt damp, and I wished I had chosen a different place to stand. But I had already started.
Trudy lowered her voice, though the people near us could still hear.
“I didn’t mean I was going to marry him.”
“That’s what you said.”
“I said it to get a rise out of you.”
Myles looked at her. “Why?”
She rubbed her thumb over the edge of the notebook. Then she shut it and put it on the table.
“I wanted him to keep coming over.”
It came out plain. No laugh this time.
Myles sat back. “You told me you needed a hand with things.”
“I did need a hand. I still do.” She glanced from him to me. “I can’t pay a repairman every time something goes wrong. And I didn’t know how to ask you to keep helping without sounding like I was asking for too much.”
“So you told my wife you’d take me from her?” I asked.
Trudy looked down at the sign. “I thought it was teasing. You looked like you could handle it.”
That was the part that got under my skin. She thought I could handle being made small because I hadn’t shouted in the church parking lot. I was angry enough to be shaky, but I didn’t raise my voice.
“You didn’t ask me what I could handle,” I said. “You just decided.”
She looked at Myles. “You never said no.”
He stared at his plate. The room had gone quiet around our table, but nobody was pretending not to listen now.
“No,” he said. “I didn’t.”
“You liked it,” I said.
He looked at me then. He didn’t dodge it.
“Yes. I liked being the one she called.”
The words hurt worse than the pies. I had been telling myself maybe he was only being kind, maybe I was jealous, maybe the whole thing was silly. He could have told me the truth weeks earlier. He could have said he liked being needed and that he was enjoying the attention. Instead he let me wonder if I had become a burden in my own marriage.
“I don’t want you,” Trudy said quickly. “I have my own life. I was lonely, and I needed help. I know how that sounds.”
“It sounds like you thought you could use my husband and make me feel foolish at the same time,” I said.
She swallowed. “I didn’t think you’d take it that way.”
Myles pushed his chair back. It scraped against the floor, loud enough to make two people turn.
“Trudy, I should have told you to stop. And I should’ve gone home when Claudette asked me to.”
“Yes,” I said. “You should have.”
He looked as if he wanted to add something. I was tired of hearing reasons before I heard an apology.
Trudy said she was sorry. She said the move had been harder than she expected, and she was embarrassed to ask for help. Her daughter had a busy life, and Trudy didn’t want to keep calling her. None of that made the words she had said to me disappear. I knew what it was to be lonely. I had been lonely sitting at my own table while my husband laughed down the hall.
“I could’ve asked you straight out,” she said.
“Yes.”
“I shouldn’t have said that about having him.”
“No.”
She pressed her lips together and looked at the people around us. Nobody rushed to rescue her from the conversation. The pastor’s wife was still watching, her hands folded on the table.
Myles pulled his chair in again, but he didn’t sit. He looked at Trudy.
“I won’t be coming over to fix anything anymore.”
She opened her mouth, then stopped. After a moment, she nodded. It wasn’t a big apology or a grand confession. It was simply the first time he had said no.
I wanted to ask him why it took a box and a roomful of people to get there. I also wanted to throw my glass of water at his shirt. I did neither. I was still angry, and I was done pretending the anger was about a pie.
Trudy closed the lid and pushed the box off her lap. “I shouldn’t have put you in the middle,” she said to me.
“You put me in it from the start.”
She looked down. “I know.”
The pastor’s wife came over and touched the back of my chair. She didn’t make a speech. She just asked if I wanted to sit beside her while the food got passed. I thanked her and stayed where I was. I wasn’t ready to be patted on the arm, but I appreciated that she hadn’t looked away.
Myles went to the other end of the table and stood there for a while. He didn’t leave the supper. Neither did I. The food got passed around again, and the fellowship hall started making its regular noise, but there was a space between us that hadn’t been there when we sat down.
After the meal, Myles carried the box to the car. I carried the casserole dish. We didn’t talk until we got home.
He set the box on the kitchen table. The bucket was still under the sink. A small brown line of water had formed on the towel beneath it.
“Claud,” he said, “I was wrong.”
I kept my coat on. “You were.”
“I thought it was harmless. I liked feeling useful. And I liked her looking at me like I was something special.” He rubbed his palm over the back of his neck. “I didn’t think enough about you.”
“That part is hard to miss.”
He nodded. I wished he had argued. It would have been easier to stay mad at him if he had.
“I can’t fix what I did by fixing the sink,” he said.
“No,” I told him. “But you can stop making me ask twice.”
He looked down toward the bucket. “I can do that.”
I didn’t tell him everything was fine. It wasn’t. I was still carrying around the picture of him grinning when Trudy said she’d have him, and the memory of him talking to her on the landline while our supper sat cold. I needed time to see whether his words held up.
On Tuesday, he didn’t take his toolbox to Trudy’s. He came home from the hardware store with the part he needed for our sink. I didn’t ask him to buy it. I was rinsing the coffee pot when he set the package on the counter.
“Is this the right one?” he asked.
I looked at the label, then at him. “It is.”
He worked under the sink while I stayed in the kitchen. I wasn’t going to turn it into a show of forgiveness. When he asked me to hold the flashlight, I held it. The bucket sat beside my foot.
A few days later, Trudy called the house. Myles picked up the landline. I heard her ask if he could come over and look at something.
He said, “I’m sorry, Trudy. I can’t.”
Then he hung up and told me he was sorry for leaving me to hear that first call alone. I didn’t say it was all forgotten. I did tell him I appreciated that he had answered her himself.
At church the next Sunday, Trudy sat with the other women. She didn’t bring a pie. Myles sat beside me, not across the room, and he didn’t look over to see whether I had noticed. I noticed anyway.
We got home before dark. He turned on the tap, and I stood by the sink while the water ran. The bucket stayed empty.