My husband canceled our Christmas Eve supper at the steakhouse because $90 was too much to spend on me this year. “We’re not made of money, hon,” he said. I hung my new green dress back in the closet, still with the tag on it. Then the steakhouse called to confirm his table for three.
Merritt and I had eaten Christmas Eve supper at the Branding Iron, out on the highway, every year for forty-four years. We ordered prime rib, baked potatoes with everything, and sat in the corner booth by the big tree. The waitresses knew us. “Merry Christmas, Ashworths. Same as always?” they’d say.
The year our girl Jolynn was born, Merritt carried her in there in a car seat. We set it on the bench beside us and took turns holding her while our food got cold. I still remembered that when the flyer came in the mail this year. I stuck it on the fridge with the magnet from the grandkids’ school and circled the Christmas Eve special in red.
Then I went to the Penney’s sale and bought the green velvet dress for thirty-four dollars. It was the first new dress I’d bought myself in three years. I kept smoothing the skirt over my knees in the car on the way home, feeling a little foolish and pleased with myself.
Merritt had always been careful with money. He retired from the rail yard nine years ago, and he still gave me sixty dollars a week for groceries and checked the receipt.
I worked thirty-one years at the shoe factory in Hannibal. My pension paid the house insurance and the lights. We’d never sat down and divided our life into his money and mine. We were married.
That morning he came in for his coffee, saw the flyer, and took it off the fridge.
“Ninety dollars for a piece of meat?” he said.
“It’s Christmas Eve, hon.”
“Not this year. The truck needs tires.” He folded the flyer twice and tucked it into his shirt pocket. “We’re not made of money, hon.”
I didn’t argue. I said, “That’s alright,” the way I usually did. My throat tightened so much I couldn’t swallow my coffee.
After he went out to the garage, I went to the bedroom and hung the dress back in the closet with its tag still on. I sat on the bed for a while. The steak didn’t matter. What hurt was the way he said it, like I’d asked him for a mink coat.
That afternoon the house phone rang. A young girl from the Branding Iron was cheerful and quick.
“Hi, this is the Branding Iron. I’m just confirming Mr. Ashworth’s reservation for Christmas Eve.”
I held on to the counter. “His reservation?”
“Yes, ma’am. A table for three, in the corner booth by the tree he asked for.”
“He wants a candle on the table, too.”
“Three,” I said.
“Yes, ma’am. Is that still right?”
I looked at the empty spot on the fridge where the flyer had been. “That’s right, honey,” I said. “Thank you for calling.”
I hung up and sat at the kitchen table. My pill organizer was in front of me, and I stared at the little T for Tuesday. For thirty years, Merritt had driven to Bowling Green every Tuesday night and every other Saturday for his union meetings. Thirty years of Tuesdays. I’d never once asked to go.
That night at supper, he told me his plans.
“I’m gonna run a ham over to my brother Alvis on Christmas Eve,” he said. “He’s all alone this year. Don’t wait up.”
“That’s sweet of you,” I said.
I meant to sound sweet. I think I did. I was too ashamed to ask why a man delivering a ham needed a table for three at our steakhouse.
For six days I didn’t say a word about the call. I ironed Merritt’s good shirts, wrapped his presents, and put them under the tree. I called Jolynn in Kansas City and talked about the grandkids like nothing was wrong. On the phone, I asked how school was going and let her tell me about their Christmas plans.
Every night I tried to give Merritt’s reservation an explanation I could live with. Maybe it was a widow from the senior center he felt sorry for. Maybe it was a buddy from the rail yard and his wife. I wanted it to be something like that. I was nervous to admit how much the other possibility hurt me.
On Christmas Eve, Merritt came out of the bedroom in his good brown jacket and the cologne I’d bought him for his birthday. He had a little wrapped box in his hand, the kind jewelry comes in. He slipped it into his coat pocket fast, but I saw.
“Back late,” he said, and kissed my cheek.
I watched his taillights go down our road. Then I went to the closet, cut the tag off the green dress, and put it on. I wore my mother’s pearl earrings and my good wool coat. I told myself I was only going to see who he’d lied to me for. I didn’t tell myself what I’d do if I found out.
I drove to the Branding Iron and sat at the very end of the bar, where I could see our corner booth by the tree. The bartender had on a Santa hat.
“What can I get you, ma’am?”
“A Coke, please,” I said. “I’m waiting on somebody.”
There was a candle lit on our table, just like Merritt had asked. A young man in his thirties sat in our booth, broad shoulders under a blue sweater, checking his watch. Something about the way he sat made my stomach turn over.
Then the front door opened and the cold came in. Merritt walked in with a woman about sixty in a red coat, her arm through his. They were laughing at something. He took her coat off for her. He hadn’t taken my coat off for me since 1990.
The hostess walked them straight back to the corner booth. They passed me without Merritt turning his head. The young man stood when he saw them. He smiled so broadly, stepped forward, and hugged my husband tight.
“Merry Christmas, Dad,” he said. “I’m glad you came.”
For a second, I thought I hadn’t heard him right. Then the woman in the red coat touched Merritt’s arm, and he looked at her with an expression I’d never seen on his face.
The young man let go. “Mom, this is Dad.”
The woman reached out to Merritt, and he took her hand. I was still standing at the end of the bar, my Coke untouched, when he finally saw me.
The young man was Merritt’s son. The woman in the red coat was his mother, a woman he had known before he met me. He had kept the son from me for forty-four years.
Merritt’s smile disappeared. The little box was still in his pocket.
“Ashley,” he said. “I can explain.”
The young man looked from Merritt to me. “You didn’t tell her?”
I felt my face tighten. “No,” I said. “He didn’t.”
The woman’s hand dropped from Merritt’s. “You told me she knew.”
“I thought I could tell her tonight,” he said.
“You told me you had,” she replied. “You said she was coming.”
That was when I understood why he’d made the reservation for three. He had planned a private dinner with the son he’d hidden and the woman who had raised him. He’d intended to tell me after he’d already brought them together. Maybe he thought that was kinder. Maybe he thought I’d be less likely to make a scene in a restaurant.
I looked at the empty fourth place that wasn’t there.
“You told me the truck needed tires,” I said.
Merritt glanced at the booth, as if the candle might give him a better answer. “I didn’t know how to say it.”
“You knew how to book a table.”
He sat down slowly. The young man stayed on his feet. The woman in the red coat looked embarrassed, but she didn’t look surprised. I wished I could say I felt sorry for her. I didn’t. I was too busy trying to fit a whole life around one sentence.
Merritt pulled out the chair beside him. “Please. Sit down. I’ll tell you everything.”
I stayed where I was. “You could’ve told me at home.”
“I was afraid you’d refuse to meet him.”
“I might have,” I said. “That was mine to decide.”
Merritt rubbed his thumb along the edge of the table. He looked older than he had that morning. I was heartbroken, and angry enough to keep my voice level.
The young man stepped closer to the booth. “I’m sorry. I thought you knew about me.”
“How long have you known he didn’t tell me?”
He looked at Merritt. “I found him through the union years ago. He said you knew he had a son.”
Merritt lowered his eyes. “I told him that.”
“Why?” I asked.
He didn’t answer right away. The woman in the red coat took her coat back from the chair and held it across her arm.
“I was young,” Merritt said. “I’d made a mess of things before I met you. I thought if I kept it separate, it wouldn’t hurt you.”
“Kept it separate for forty-four years?”
He rubbed his forehead. “I didn’t know how to bring it up later.”
“That’s not the same as not knowing.”
“I know.”
The young man’s smile was gone now. He looked at me with the worried, careful expression people use when they’re afraid they’ve walked into the wrong room.
“My mother raised me,” he said. “I’m not here to ask you for anything.”
I believed that he believed it. It didn’t make me feel better. My husband had sat across from me through decades of Christmas suppers, and every year he’d let me think there was nothing in his life I didn’t know.
I looked at the woman. “Did you know he was married to me?”
“Yes,” she said. She didn’t try to make it sound better. “He told me he’d told you. I should’ve asked.”
Merritt shook his head. “Don’t put this on her.”
“I’m not,” I said. “I’m asking her what she knew.”
The woman held my gaze. “I knew about you. I believed him when he said you knew about his son.”
That answer hurt in a different way. The woman wasn’t there to take my place. She’d been living with the same lie, in her own way. But Merritt had made a choice for both of us. He’d decided we could each be told whatever kept the rest of his life comfortable.
The little wrapped box showed under his hand when he reached for his coat pocket.
“What’s in there?” I asked.
He stopped. “A rail-yard pin. It belonged to my father. I wanted to give it to him.”
The young man glanced at the box. “You said it was Dad’s.”
“It was,” Merritt said. “I kept it all these years.”
I looked at that small box and remembered the way he’d slipped it into his pocket as if he didn’t want me to see. His secret had been old, but the lying was still happening in front of me.
“Did you ever plan to tell me before tonight?” I asked.
“Yes,” he said.
“When?”
He looked down at the table. “I don’t know.”
That answer was honest, at least. I hated that it was the first honest thing he’d said.
The young man pulled the chair back out, but didn’t sit. “I don’t want to cause trouble between you.”
“You didn’t cause it,” I said. “You walked into it.”
Merritt started to speak, and I put one hand up.
“No. I’ve spent six days making excuses for you. I’m done doing that tonight.”
His face tightened. “I didn’t want to hurt you.”
“You did hurt me. You just didn’t want to watch it happen.”
It got quiet around our booth. At the next table, a man lowered his fork. The waitress with the Santa hat paused near the service station, then kept her eyes on the floor. I hated that strangers had heard me say it, but I wasn’t going to swallow those words for Merritt’s comfort.
He stood. “Let’s go home and talk.”
“Go to Alvis’s,” I said. “You told me you were taking him a ham. Go do that.”
Merritt stared at me. “I can’t leave you here.”
“I drove myself.”
The woman in the red coat quietly put her coat on. The young man held the booth open for her, and then he looked at Merritt.
“We can leave,” he said. “We can talk another day.”
I looked at him. “I don’t know what I want from you yet. I’m sorry you were made part of this without knowing.”
He nodded, and I could see he was trying not to look relieved. The woman gave me a small, awkward nod, then she and the young man walked toward the door. Merritt stayed by the booth.
“Please come home with me,” he said.
“I will go home,” I told him. “You’re not coming with me tonight.”
He started to argue. Then his eyes went to the tables around us, and he stopped. He took the little box from his pocket and set it on the table beside the candle.
I didn’t touch it.
He went out alone. I watched him cross the parking lot through the front windows and get into his truck. He sat there for a while before driving off.
The bartender came over to ask if I wanted anything else. I told him I was fine, though my Coke was still full. I paid for it and drove home in the green dress.
Merritt was gone when I got there. I took off my coat and set my mother’s pearl earrings in their little dish. Then I called Jolynn. I told her the truth, not all of it in one breath, but enough. She didn’t interrupt. When I finished, she said she’d call me in the morning.
I slept in our bed alone. In the morning, Merritt called from Alvis’s and asked if he could come back. I told him he could come for his clothes, but we weren’t going to pretend that one conversation fixed forty-four years of silence. He came by while I was out, and Alvis helped him take what he needed. The house stayed mine to live in, and the bills stayed as they’d been. I didn’t have to decide our whole marriage before breakfast.
The green dress went back in my closet, tagless and ready to wear. The little T on my pill organizer was for Tuesday. I moved it to the other side of the table and left the chair beside me empty.