But when Toby was 12, the trust fund matured to a point where the bank sent a statement to our house. The envelope was sitting on the kitchen counter when Misty suddenly showed up on our porch.

She wasn’t alone. She had a lawyer with her, a tall man in a cheap suit named Arthur Vance.

Misty looked different. She was wearing expensive sunglasses, carrying a glossy handbag, and smiling. She didn’t look like she had abandoned her toddler 10 years ago. She looked like she was there to collect a package.

“Thanks for your services! I will take it from here,” Misty said with a pleasant smile, walking past me into my house.

My stomach dropped. I stood in the hallway, my jaw locking so tightly my teeth hurt. I whispered that he was 12, that he had a life here with his school and his friends, but Misty didn’t care.

She calmly replied that he was her son and that the court had given her the final word, and her lawyer Vance handed me the custody papers. Because Gregory had signed away his rights and I was only the grandmother, the court had granted her custody.

I didn’t scream. I didn’t yell. I stood there like a statue while Toby started crying, clutching his grandfather’s silver pocket watch to his chest. Misty snatched the watch from him, saying it belonged to her family now, and packed his few belongings into a trash bag.

Misty told me not to make a scene, saying it was better this way.

I watched the car drive away. Toby was looking out the back window, his face wet with tears. I stood on the porch for 2 hours, holding the green knit blanket he had left behind. The house was cold and empty.

The years that followed were pure hell.

Misty moved Toby to a small town near Indianapolis. She blocked my phone number. She returned my letters unopened.

Not on Thanksgiving.
Not on Christmas.
Not when I had knee surgery.
Not when Arthur’s sister died.

I sat in my quiet house and wondered if I had failed him. Maybe I should have fought harder when he was 12. Maybe I should have hired my own lawyer, even if it cost every penny of Arthur’s pension.